Skip to main content

Matt McLain could lead a Reds roster purge before the non-tender deadline

This could get interesting.
ByDrew Koch
Cincinnati Reds, Matt McLain
Cincinnati Reds, Matt McLain | Kathryn May/GettyImages

With the lockout looming, the Major League Baseball offseason is headed for a immediate stop on December 1. But before business comes to a screeching halt, teams will need to make an evaluation of their current 40-man roster with the non-tender deadline rapidly approaching.

The deadline itself is set for Friday, November 20, and the Cincinnati Reds have a number of potential roster casualties. Though the Reds' list of non-tender candidates could easily be more than a dozen players, no name is more recognizable than former first-round pick Matt McLain.

Matt McLain headlines the Reds who could be non-tendered this week

McLain is coming off back-to-back seasons in which he failed to live up to the standard he set during his rookie season in 2023. He burst onto the scene that season and finished fifth in the Rookie of the Year voting after hitting .290/.357/.507 with 16 home runs and 50 RBI.

But after missing the 2024 campaign with a shoulder injury, McLain's combined to post a mediocre .204/.288/.339 slash line and 74 OPS+ over the past two seasons. Were it not for his elite-level of play in the field, McLain may've spent the second-half of the 2026 season in the minor leagues.

MLB Trade Rumors projects the 27-year-old to pocket $4 million through arbitration next season, and that money could be better spent shoring up the bullpen or the starting rotation. It's difficult to see Cincinnati making the decision to non-tender McLain before Friday's deadline, but a trade is certainly possible.

Which Reds players besides Matt McLain could be non-tendered this week?

McLain isn't the only notable Reds' player to keep an eye ahead of Friday's non-tender deadline. Let's take a look at the cases for Tony Santillan, Brandon Williamson, JJ Bleday, and Noelvi Marte.

Tony Santillan, Reds reliever

Santillan had a disappointing season in 2026 that ended with a season-ending trip to the injured list and, eventually, hip surgery. The hulking right-hander is presumed to be ready for spring training next year, but which version of Santillan will the Reds get in 2027?

If it's the one who logged 73⅔ innings over 80 appearances in 2025 and posted a 2.44 ERA, sign us up. But if Santillan's struggles from this past season (6.42 ERA in just 44 appearances) are indicative of the type of pitcher he'll be in 2027, the Reds might consider cutting ties before Friday's deadline.

Brandon Williamson, Reds starter

Williamson worked his tail off to make the Reds' Opening Day roster in 2026, but ultimately only started nine games. The left-hander was, at one time, highly regarded throughout the organization, but various injuries have limited him to just 16 appearances over the last three years.

Williamson is only expected to receive a modest raise through arbitration (~$1.3 million), and given the current price for starting pitching on the open market, it's difficult to see the Reds non-tendering the southpaw before the deadline. But next season will likely be a make-it or break-campaign for the former top prospect.

JJ Bleday, Reds outfielder

Bleday is an interesting case. Cincinnati got the former Athletics outfielder for a bargain last winter, but MLBTR's arbitration estimate projects he'll make somewhere in the neighborhood of $5 million in 2027. If Bleday is able to produce at the level Reds fans saw to begin the 2026 season, that's a veritable steal.

But Bleday's numbers took a nose dive after the All-Star break. He still managed to crush 24 homers, and Cincinnati's lack of outfield depth likely keeps him around past the non-tender deadline. But if another team comes calling at some point this offseason, fans shouldn't rule out a possible trade involving the former first-round pick.

Noelvi Marte, Reds outfielder

Marte is the only one of this group who isn't in line for a raise through arbitration. For that reason alone, he'll probably avoid being non-tendered. But that doesn't mean Cincinnati won't look to shop Marte this offseason.

There seemed to be a sense after the season that Marte's effort just wasn't there in 2026. Both Nick Krall and Terry Francona didn't exactly have kind things to say about the infielder turned outfielder, and he could be a prime change-of-scenery candidate if another club comes calling.

There are others on the Reds' roster who are in a much more precarious position than the group of McLain, Santillan, Williamson, Bleday, and Marte.

Right-handers Zach Maxwell, Duncan Davitt, Paxton Schultz, Chase Solesky, and Carson Spiers could all be jettisoned later this week, along with catcher Will Banfield and infield prospect Leo Balcazar.

Add us as a preferred source on Google