Skip to main content

Reds dodged a costly bullet as White Sox overpay for Dustin May

How much?
ByDrew Koch
Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch
Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Cincinnati Reds rumored to be in the mix for free agent starting pitcher Dustin May. But the Chicago White Sox swooped in and forked over $52.5 million to sign the two-time World Series champion to a three-year deal. That has the makings of a massive overpay on the part of the White Sox.

May had a fine year in 2026, but it was the best of his seven big-league seasons. The right-hander began the season with the St. Louis Cardinals and was traded to the Milwaukee Brewers at the August 3 deadline. In total, he started 31 games and logged just under 150 innings while racking up 144 punch outs.

But May has endured his fair share of injuries over the years, and across his previous six seasons prior to 2026, only made 71 appearances including 57 starts while pitching for the Los Angeles Dodgers and Boston Red Sox. With durability issues like that, there was no way the Reds were going to commit to an average annual value of $17.5 million.

Reds avoided massive overpay for Dustin May, but the market is getting expensive

If a pitcher like May, who's a mid-rotation starter with durability concerns, is taking home more than $17 million per season, then the cost of starting pitching is fixing to go through the roof. Maybe the Reds should've extended that qualifying offer to Brady Singer after all. (They were right not to.)

But it certainly strengthens the notion of the Reds re-signing Singer this offseason. If a pitcher like May can secure a three-year deal, Singer will surely be able to land a two-year pact. The 30-year-old endured a tough stretch with the Reds in 2026, but he answers the bell every fifth day and has eclipsed 150 innings pitched each of the past five seasons.

If it's not Singer, the Reds might turn their attention to one of Nick Martinez, David Peterson, or Casey Mize. But based on May's contract details, all three of those pitchers will be looking for multi-year deals.

So while Cincinnati certainly avoided disaster by staying away from a long-term commitment to May, it would appear that adding starting pitching this winter is going to be very costly.

Add us as a preferred source on Google