Skip to main content

Royce Lewis (and five other names to watch) for Reds as non-tender deadline decisions could reshape roster

Keep a sharp eye.
ByDrew Koch
Minnesota Twins first baseman Royce Lewis (23) celebrates
Minnesota Twins first baseman Royce Lewis (23) celebrates | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The non-tender deadline is quickly approaching. Major League Baseball teams have until 5:00 p.m. ET to decide whether or not they want to tender contracts to all pre-arb and arbitration eligible players who are on their 40-man roster.

The Cincinnati Reds roster currently sits at 38, and all 11 players who are up for arbitration are likely to be tendered a contract for the 2027 season. Some have speculated that Matt McLain or Tony Santillan might be among the Reds' roster casualties, but that seems unlikely.

Nevertheless, the Cincinnati faithful might want to keep an eye on the upcoming non-tender deadline. Not necessarily for transactions the Reds might make, but other organizations throughout MLB will making some tough decisions about whether or not to free up some much-needed roster spots or shed some unnecessary payroll.

One name who's being viewed as potential non-tender candidate is Minnesota Twins infielder, and former No. 1 overall draft pick, Royce Lewis. The 27-year-old's career has been defined by injuries, and after a second consecutive season with an OPS below .700, many industry sources believe he could either be traded or non-tendered before the 5 p.m. ET deadline on Friday.

Lewis can play both corner infield spots, but spent far more time at first base in 2026. If he were to become available, Cincinnati could add him to their roster and move Sal Stewart across the diamond to third base — something a number of fans have already been clamoring for this offseason.

Despite his recent struggles, Lewis still maintains a career 102 OPS+, and still possesses tremendous speed and power. Trading for him with an estimated salary of $5.1 million would be quite the gamble for the Reds, but if he's non-tendered by the Twins, Cincinnati's front office would be foolish not to at least make a play for the former first-rounder.

But Lewis isn't the only non-tender candidate Reds fans should be keeping an eye before the deadline passes. Let's look at five other players who could be on the Reds' radar with the non-tender deadline just hours away.

Royce Lewis isn't the only non-tender candidate the Reds fans should be watching for

Matt Wallner, Twins outfielder

Lewis' Minnesota teammate, Matt Wallner, could be a player who's cut loose ahead of the non-tender deadline. He's struggled with swing-and-miss in the past, but recorded 22 home runs in 2025. He played in just 34 games last season after being optioned to the minor leagues barely a month into the 2026 campaign.

Wallner has a cannon for an arm, though his range in the outfield is limited. His left-handed swing makes him less than ideal fit alongside JJ Bleday, Carlos Jorge, and Héctor Rodriguez, but would give the Reds insurance in the event that one of their youngsters struggle next season. Wallner is still pre-arbitration eligible, so the money is not a factor.

Luis Gil, Yankees pitcher

Luis Gil will be a popular name at this year's non-tender deadline. It would seem that almost every Yankees fan and insider expects New York to cut ties, and given Cincinnati's need for pitching depth, adding the right-hander makes a ton of sense.

Gil is still just 28 years old and was named AL Rookie of the Year in 2024. Injuries have limited him to just 84⅓ innings over the last two seasons, however, and the Yankees can no longer option him to the minor leagues. His arbitration number is expected to be less than $2.5 million, making him the perfect type of buy-low arm Cincinnati should have their eye on.

Alex Call, Dodgers outfielder

Most Reds fans seem to be in consensus here; if Alex Call is non-tendered, the Reds should snag him almost immediately. Call fits the Reds' roster perfectly — very similar to Dane Myers — in that he could be platooned alongside JJ Bleday in left field.

Call's splits against left-handed pitching (.264/.350/.412 with a 112 wRC+) would give Terry Francona an alternative to Bleday when a southpaw is on the bump. His salary estimate in Year 1 of his arbitration window is less than $2 million. Adding Call is no-brainer if he's made available at the non-tender deadline.

Mark Vientos, Mets infielder

Mark Vientos has been connected to the Reds in trade talks in the past, but after hitting just .212/.258/.394 with the New York Mets this past season, his chances of being available on the free-agent market are becoming more and more likely. Vientos has seen his stock plummet since hitting .266/.322/.516 with a 131 wRC+ in 2024.

Vientos, much like the aforementioned Lewis, can play both first and third base. So, much the previous scenario, adding him to the roster would allow Cincinnati to push Stewart to the hot corner as needed to cover for the anemic bat of Ke'Bryan Hayes. Vientos' arb estimates have come in below $3 million, making his addition to the Reds roster rather simple if they choose to go that route.

Ronel Blanco, Astros pitcher

Finally, let's look at another arm. Ronel Blanco is a bit of surprise name to find on a list of potential non-tender candidates, but with Randy Flores taking over in the Astros' front office, no one really knows what direction Houston is going to take this offseason.

Blanco missed most of last season while recovering from Tommy John surgery and didn't look great upon his return. Such is the case, however, for pitchers who've been gone for over a year. If Blanco is cut loose, he could be a nice addition for a Reds rotation seeking to add depth.

Add us as a preferred source on Google