Skip to main content

Reds should not let growing competition scare them off Rays catcher

Get it done.
ByDrew Koch
New York Yankees right fielder Jasson Dominguez (24) is tagged out at home plate bu Tampa Bay Rays catcher Nick Fortes
New York Yankees right fielder Jasson Dominguez (24) is tagged out at home plate bu Tampa Bay Rays catcher Nick Fortes | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Cincinnati Reds general manager Brad Meador made no bones about it during an appearance on the Reds Hot Stove League radio show earlier this week; replacing Tyler Stephenson behind the plate is one of the organization's top priorities this offseason. Perhaps the Tampa Bay Rays could provide the solution Reds are looking for.

According to Mark Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times, the Rays are fielding offers for catcher Nick Fortes. Formerly of the Miami Marlins, Fortes has spent the past year and half with Tampa Bay, but with Liam Hicks and Kenny Piper on the 40-man roster, plus Caden Bodine working his way up through the Rays' farm system, the 30-year-old backstop has become expendable.

Topkin is reporting that the Rays are in negotiations with multiple clubs, and while nothing is set in stone, it sounds as if a trade is imminent. This is one of those instances where the Reds — if they value Fortes — need to be somewhat aggressive and make a bold move to acquire the Rays' backstop.

Fortes is far from the only option out there. The San Diego Padres are known to be shopping Luis Campusano and Freddy Fermin, and the Chicago White Sox just designated Joey Bart for assignment. But Fortes posted adequate numbers for the Rays last season, and would give Cincinnati the type of stopgap option they need with Alfredo Duno still over a year away from making it to the big leagues.

Rays catcher Nick Fortes could provide the Reds with depth behind the dish

Last season, Fortes appeared in 109 games and hit .258/.304/.376 with six home runs and a 90 wRC+. Normally an above-average defender, Fortes' advanced metrics took a step back in 2026 , but his career numbers (8 DRS and 12 OAA) suggest he's still a better receiver than Stephenson (-27 DRS and -34 OAA).

Stephenson's market is set to take off after Ryan Jeffers accepted the Minnesota Twins qualifying offer. The Twins will now sign a $23.1 million check to keep Jeffers around next season, meaning Stephenson and former Chicago Cubs catcher Carson Kelly stand to make a fortune on the open market. There are other low-cost free agent options available, but the trade route would provide Cincinnati with a much more ideal replacement behind the plate.

If, as Meador suggested, finding a replacement for Stephenson is a priority, the Reds' front office needs to strike quickly. Cincinnati cannot afford to go into the 2027 season with Jose Trevino and Will Banfield as the only catchers on the roster. It's time to make a deal.

Add us as a preferred source on Google