It always felt like a reunion between the Cincinnati Reds and Tyler Stephenson was a long shot, but Ryan Jeffers decision to accept the qualifying offer from the Minnesota Twins just took those odds from slim to absolute zero.
Jeffers was slapped with a qualifying offer earlier this offseason, meaning that he could either accept the Twins' generous proposal to pay him $23.1 million in 2027, or reject it, and enter the free agent market with draft compensation attached to his signing. Jeffers chose the former, and that will take Stephenson's price tag even higher than most already assumed.
Ryan Jeffers accepted Twins' QO, effectively pricing the Reds out of Tyler Stephenson's market
Reds' GM Brad Meador made an appearance on the Reds Hot Stove League radio show earlier this week and was consistently talking about Stephenson in the past tense, while at the same time speaking about how Cincinnati needs to replace him. If that's the not clearest sign yet that he's not returning to the Reds' organization, we don't know what is.
With Jeffers now off market, Stephenson becomes arguably the most coveted backstop available in free agency. Some might argue for Carson Kelly, and that's fair, but both are expected to sign contracts with eight-figure AAVs.
That's a number the Reds just can't chase, especially with so many other holes on the roster and top prospect Alfredo Duno tracking toward his Major League debut sometime within the next two years.
Fans should probably expect the Reds to turn their focus toward the trade market. Names like Nick Fortes (Tampa Bay Rays) along with Freddy Fermin and Luis Campusano (San Diego Padres) would be stopgap options and would cost little more than a low-level prospect. All three have at least two years of team control remaining and are predicted to take home less than $3 million through arbitration.
The expected loss of Stephenson — whenever he signs a new deal in free agency — will certainly sting. His first big-league swing resulted in a home run, and he instantly became a fan-favorite in the city of Cincinnati. But if the Reds plan to compete in 2027, they need to make wise and savvy investments. Re-signing Stephenson does not qualify.
