Skip to main content

White Sox DFA gives Reds a timely chance to address catching need

An underrated option.
ByStephen Parello
Joey Bart
Joey Bart | G Fiume/GettyImages

The Cincinnati Reds need a catcher who can at least share the workload with Jose Trevino behind the plate and keep the seat warm for top prospect Alfredo Duno, who likely won't be arriving until 2028. The ideal option would be reuniting with Tyler Stephenson on a two-year pact, but that seemed unlikely from the start.

The probability of Stephenson coming back to the Queen City took another hit ahead of the November 17 qualifying offer decision deadline, when Ryan Jeffers surprisingly decided to take the one-year, $23.15 million deal to return to the Minnesota Twins.

Jeffers coming off the board leaves Stephenson firmly as the top free-agent option, increasing his leverage in negotiations and all but confirming that he'll be priced out of Cincinnati's budget.

But November 17 also served as the last day teams could add prospects to their 40-man rosters to protect them from the Rule 5 Draft (if it actually happens). This set off a flurry of moves, with "dead weight" being cut from rosters in order to preserve future assets. One such player who got the axe from the Chicago White Sox was veteran catcher Joey Bart.

Bart might not be a superstar, but the 30-year-old adds some needed depth to the pool of free-agent backstops and could present the Reds with an intriguing yet low-cost option.

Signing Joey Bart is a gamble that the Reds should make

Trying to figure out exactly what Joey Bart is is a tough task. He was the No. 2 overall pick in the 2018 draft by the San Francisco Giants, but mostly flamed out in the Bay Area before being traded to the Pittsburgh Pirates in April of 2024.

Bart's 2024 and 2025 campaigns in Pittsburgh were both good, but in drastically different ways. In 2024, he slashed .265/.337/.462 with 13 home runs over 80 games in what was a power-focused approach. In 2025, the power dissipated, but Bart upped his walk rate substantially, rising from 7.8% to 12% en route to a .249/.355/.340 season with four homers over 93 contests.

It's weird to see those kinds of swings in terms of power and plate discipline, and if we look to 2026 to find context, we'll be left with more questions than answers. Bart missed significant time this year, first due to a nasty foot infection that required IV antibiotics, and then went down with a fractured left hand after being hit by a pitch in August. In the meantime, the Pirates traded him to the Atlanta Braves in June, and then the Braves traded him to the Chicago White Sox at the August 3 deadline.

Amid all the turmoil, Bart played just 44 games and hit a disappointing .214/.305/.357. It's hard to really blame him for the poor production, as he was never able to find a groove and was uprooted twice.

Still, he has a top prospect pedigree, some recent history of production, and will come very cheap, making this the kind of high-upside signing the Reds need to be making. If paired with Trevino, who is the better defender and who does have some offensive merits, Cincinnati may be able to extract average or better performance from the duo.

At the risk of sounding like a broken record, the objective for the Reds isn't to get the best available player in the budget at every position of need. Instead, it's finding a way to spread the limited money around to fill as many holes as possible and make the entire unit greater than the sum of its parts.

With Bart's past history as a league-average or better hitter in 2024 and 2025, plus whatever potential is left in him given his draft status, he'll give the club more upside than any other option at a similar price point. That alone makes rolling the dice a worthwhile endeavor.

Add us as a preferred source on Google