Skip to main content

Reds have an obvious Matt McLain trade decision that could solve two problems

Seems like the prudent thing to do.
ByDrew Koch
Cincinnati Reds, Matt McLain
Cincinnati Reds, Matt McLain | Isaac Wasserman/GettyImages

Will the Cincinnati Reds non-tender Matt McLain ahead of Friday's deadline? That seems unlikely. But that doesn't mean another avenue doesn't exist that would allow the Reds to part ways with their starting second baseman. Might we see Cincinnati trade McLain before Friday's non-tender deadline?

It's certainly plausible. McLain has the former top prospect pedigree and fits nicely into that "change-of-scenery" category. If he was traded, it would free up an extra $4 million or so from the Reds' budget heading into next season.

There's also the elephant in the room, and that is Edwin Arroyo's presence on the 40-man roster. Though the former top prospect put up an unimpressive .223/.266/.264 slash line in 160 plate appearances during his rookie season, McLain's numbers weren't much better (.185/.274/.334).

The Reds owe it both Arroyo and the organization to give their young infielder a longer runway to see if he's up to the challenge. But with McLain and Elly De La Cruz on the roster, everyday reps will be hard to come by.

With all that as a backdrop, why wouldn't the Reds actually consider trading McLain this offseason?

The Reds should at least make Matt McLain available in trade talks this offseason

The short answer is, they should. The Reds' roster has more holes than Firestone Country Club, and they're going to need every penny available in order to cobble together a group of 26 players who'll give the team a fighting chance in 2027. Trading McLain would save Cincinnati enough money to at least add a middle reliever through free agency.

Though he's endured back-to-back down years at the dish, McLain's defense at the keystone is near flawless, and he would have no shortage of suitors if the Reds made him available this offseason. A team like the New York Yankees, Atlanta Braves, or even his hometown Los Angeles Dodgers would love to add an inexpensive middle infielder with team control.

The Reds have spoken about retooling rather than rebuilding for the 2027 season, and that's exactly what trading McLain would allow them to do. The organization has plenty of in-house options to take over at second base, and if dealing McLain would either bring back Major League-caliber talent in return or allow the front office to spend more money in free agency, Cincinnati has to be willing to take that risk.

Unless the Reds' brass has visions of giving McLain more reps in center field next spring — something they shouldn't have considered in the first place — they should give thought to the idea of trading him this winter for the best possible return.

Add us as a preferred source on Google