Skip to main content

Reds fans have limited window to appreciate Elly De La Cruz after Silver Slugger win

Elly capped off a spectacular 2026 season with a Silver Slugger, but questions about his future remain.
ByDrew Koch
Cincinnati Reds shortstop Elly de la Cruz (44) heads off the field
Cincinnati Reds shortstop Elly de la Cruz (44) heads off the field | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Congratulations are in order for Cincinnati Reds shortstop Elly De La Cruz. The Reds' star is taking home his first-ever Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Award, besting Washington Nationals shortstop CJ Abrams and Miami Marlins infielder Otto Lopez for the honor. Elly is the first Reds' player since Nick Castellanos in 2021 to take home the Silver Slugger Award.

De La Cruz earned it with his first ever 30-30 season, joining Reds' Hall of Famers Eric Davis (1987), Barry Larkin (1996), and Brandon Phillips (2007) as the only players in Cincinnati history to register such a feat.

There's plenty of reason for celebration, but De La Cruz's victory comes at an odd time in the franchise's history. The Reds' shortstop has become the subject of numerous trade rumors this winter, and while Nick Krall and the front office have downplayed all the noise, the harsh reality is that De La Cruz's time in Cincinnati is quickly coming to an end.

Elly De La Cruz's Silver Slugger win comes at somber time for Reds fans

De La Cruz is a gererational talent, and as such, he's going to command an outlandish salary once he reaches free agency. Some Reds fans are holding out hope that the upcoming Collective Bargaining negotiations might yeield a salary cap and floor — which would completely change the spending dynamics throughout Major League Baseball — but the Players Association has called such antics on the part of of MLB and the owners, a non-starter.

The harsh reality for Reds fans is that next season might be De La Cruz's last in a Cincinnati uniform. Some are even advocating for the Reds to just go ahead of trade Elly this winter. That seems a bit rash, though it's certainly possible if Krall and Co. are blown away by another team's offer.

Small-market clubs like the Reds have a limited window with superstars like De La Cruz, something that was magnified by last year's shortcomings. After going to the postseason in 2025, many Reds fans were hopeful to see De La Cruz lead Cincinnati back to the playoffs in 2026. Instead, the club finished below .500 and the outlook for 2027 is rather bleak at the moment.

De La Cruz deserves praise for his 2026 performance and this latest recognition with the NL Silver Slugger Award among shortstops. But what lies ahead is far less glamorous, and Reds fans are already forecasting a future without their superstar.

Add us as a preferred source on Google