Skip to main content

2026 Silver Slugger Predictions: Sal Stewart eyes more hardware, Elly De La Cruz takes aim

So you're telling me there's a chance.
ByDrew Koch
Elly De La Cruz, Sal Stewart
Elly De La Cruz, Sal Stewart | Kylie Bridenhagen/GettyImages

The Cincinnati Reds have two finalists for the 2026 Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards presented by FanSided. Will Sal Stewart or Elly De La Cruz take home their very first Silver Slugger Award this week?

There was little doubt that De La Cruz would be among the Silver Slugger finalists at shortstop this season. He became a member of the 30-30 club with 30 home runs and 30 stolen bases while also hitting .283/.365/.515 with a 142 OPS+ and a 139 wRC+.

But Stewart's inclusion was a bit of a surprise. Though he took home NL Rookie of the Year honors, and rightfully so, his bat cooled off in September and led to a final line of .263/.330/.457 with 32 homers, 112 RBI, a 117 OPS+, and a 112 wRC+.

Stewart's performance wasn't enough to land him among the top first basemen for this year's Silver Slugger Award, but his defensive versatility allowed him to be named a finalist in the utility player category. Stewart played 117 games at first base and another 45 at the hot corner.

But the competition for both Reds' stars is stiff. Let's take a look at the other National League hitters who are vying to outlast De La Cruz and Stewart for this year's Silver Slugger honors.

Reds' stars Elly De La Cruz & Sal Stewart have tough competition for Silver Slugger Awards

Let's look at the competition facing De La Cruz first, shall we? The Reds superstar has two other infielders staring him down for the top spot among National League slugging shortstops: CJ Abrams (Washington Nationals) and Otto Lopez (Miami Marlins).

All three players have merit, with each earning the nod in their own unique way. De La Cruz leads the way in the power department, even though Abrams had more big flies in 2026. The Nats' shortstop led the group in RBI, but Lopez has the edge in batting average.

Elly De La Cruz

CJ Abrams

Otto Lopez

.283 BA

.261 BA

.305 BA

.365 OBP

.336 OBP

.349 OBP

.515 SLG

.497 SLG

.437 SLG

30 HR

33 HR

11 HR

79 RBI

106 RBI

71 RBI

142 OPS+

127 OPS+

122 OPS+

But when you put all the stats side-by-side, it becomes apparent that De La Cruz should be the run-away winner for this year's Silver Slugger Award among National League shortstops. Abrams may give him a run for his money, but in the end, expect to see the Reds' shortstop taking home the trophy.

Prediction: Elly De La Cruz wins 2026 National League Silver Slugger Award (SS)

Let's flip over to Stewart's case for the NL Silver Slugger Award among utility players. Unlike De La Cruz, Stewart faces more of an uphill climb if he hopes to take home another trophy for his mantle. The Reds' rookie has the unfortunate task of going head-to-head against San Diego Padres' All-Star Fernando Tatis Jr. and the NLCS MVP Jake Bauers.

Sal Stewart

Fernando Tatis Jr.

Jake Bauers

.263 BA

.289 BA

.266 BA

.330 OBP

.358 OBP

.389 OBP

.457 SLG

.470 SLG

.484 SLG

32 HR

25 HR

26 HR

112 RBI

83 RBI

86 RBI

117 OPS+

130 OPS+

140 OPS+

Stewart maintains the edge in homers and RBI, but if we're applying the same criteria to this race as the other, it's going to be difficult to hand the award to the Reds' slugger. Tatis and Bauers are neck and neck, though Bauers has a slight edge in every category outside of batting average.

Unfortunately for Reds fans, Stewart likely falls short of claiming his first Silver Slugger Award this year, but look for the 22-year-old to be right back in the mix next season.

Prediction: Fernando Tatis Jr. wins 2026 National League Silver Slugger Award (UTL)

Add us as a preferred source on Google