Skip to main content

Orioles’ Ketel Marte trade rumors could hand the Reds an unexpected second base solution

Keep an eye on this one.
ByDrew Koch
Arizona Diamondbacks designated hitter Ketel Marte
Arizona Diamondbacks designated hitter Ketel Marte | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Last offseason, there was a lot of trade chatter surrounding the Cincinnati Reds and Arizona Diamondbacks' superstar Ketel Marte. The buzz eventually fizzled out and Marte remained in the desert this past season. Given the All-Star's constant off-the-field drama, Cincinnati was wise to avoid such a deal last winter.

But the Baltimore Orioles appear to be kicking the tires on a potential trade for Marte this offseason. The O's have reportedly spoken with the D-backs about a deal centered around Arizona's star second baseman, but sources say that no trade is imminent.

If the Orioles strike a deal with the Diamondbacks and bring Marte to Baltimore, it offers the Reds an intriguing opportunity to improve their club. Orioles infielder Jackson Holliday would suddenly become expendable, and Cincinnati may be in line to make a play for the former first-overall pick.

Orioles' trade interest in Ketel Marte could open the door for the Reds to land Jackson Holliday

Holliday hasn't lived up to the hype that comes with being the No. 1-overall pick and the son of a seven-time All-Star (Matt Holliday). Baltimore accelerated Holliday's ascension through the minors, and he debuted less than two years after being drafted. He made the Orioles' Opening Day roster in 2024, but played in just 60 games and hit .189/.255/.311 with a 63 OPS+.

Holliday appeared to find his footing the following season, playing in 149 games while hitting a more respectable .242/.314/.375 with 17 home runs, 55 RBI, and 17 stolen bases. But he failed to take the next step this past season and posted a disappointing .229/.300/.340 slash line with just seven homers and 30 RBI over 98 games.

While that's certainly not the type of production a team expects to see from their former first-round pick, Holliday suffered a hamate injury last spring and was sidelined for first two months of the season. These injuries typically sap a hitter of power, and that's exactly what fans saw last season. He'll be more than a year removed from the procedure in 2027, and one has wonder if he'll finally be ready to live up to the lofty standards assigned to him as a teenager.

If the Orioles execute a trade with the D-backs and bring Marte to the East Coast, Reds' president Nick Krall should link up with his counterpart in Baltimore, Mike Elias, and find out what it would take to bring Holliday to Cincinnati.

The Reds have given Matt McLain ample time to carve out a permanent role at second base, but to date, he's failed to grab ahold of that elusive brass ring. The O's won't just give Holliday away for nothing, but his trade value is nowhere near what it would've been two or three years ago. If Cincinnati's coaching staff feels like they can fix what's gone wrong, this is the type of high-risk/ high-reward move Krall and Co. must make if they hope to make some noise in 2027.

Holliday still has minor-league options remaining and won't reach arbitration until after next season. The Reds could then look to trade McLain or, do what they did last season, and give him some extra reps in the outfield next spring. Either way, Holliday should be on Cincinnati's radar if he becomes available.

Add us as a preferred source on Google