Skip to main content

Cubs just made the Reds' search for Tyler Stephenson's replacement harder

Another one off the board.
ByDrew Koch
Pittsburgh Pirates catcher Joey Bart (14) dives and misses a foul ball
Pittsburgh Pirates catcher Joey Bart (14) dives and misses a foul ball | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Arguably the biggest question facing the Cincinnati Reds at the moment is how they plan to replace Tyler Stephenson behind the plate. Though the longtime Reds' catcher is still on the free-agent market, after Ryan Jeffers accepted the Minnesota Twins qualifying offer earlier this week, Stephenson's price tag likely went well beyond a number the Reds would be comfortable paying.

As such, the Reds will be hunting for Stephenson's replacement and are no doubt looking for a bargain. A solution appeared to present itself earlier this week after the Chicago White Sox designated Joey Bart for assignment in order to clear a roster spot for newly-signed starting pitcher Dustin May.

But the Reds' division rivals reportedly beat them to the punch. According to FanSided's MLB insider Robert Murray, the Chicago Cubs acquired Bart. It hasn't been reported whether or not the acquisition came via trade or a waiver claim, but either way, Bart won't be coming to Cincinnati.

Reds are running out of options after Cubs acquire Joey Bart following White Sox's DFA

Would Bart have fixed all of Cincinnati's problems? No, not even close. But at the moment, the only two catchers on the Reds' 40-man roster are Jose Trevino and Will Banfield. In 52 games last season, Trevino hit just .217 with a 46 wRC+. Banfield is little more than a minor-league journeyman who made his big-league debut last season out of necessity after Trevino landed on the injured list. He appeared in 11 games and recorded just three bases hits. Neither player is an everyday catcher.

That's not to say the Reds need an everyday backstop. More and more, teams are willing to create a timeshare behind the plate, and with the budgetary restrictions Cincinnati's front office is surely facing, that's likely the direction the Reds will take heading into 2027. The club needs little more than a stopgap option until top prospect Alfredo Duno is ready for The Show.

That's why adding a player like Bart would've been a fine addition to the Reds' roster. Pitchers like throwing to him, he's got enough pop to be dangerous (career .368 slugging percentage with a 94 wRC+), and will be a free agent after the upcoming season. But alas, the Cubs jumped the line, and the Reds are still left without a capable backstop to pair alongside Trevino in 2027.

The one silver lining to emerge from this transaction is that former Cubs' catcher, Carson Kelly, is unlikely to return to the North Side. If the Reds are really looking for an upgrade behind the dish, they could chase the 32-year-old veteran. But with all the holes in the Reds' roster, finding a low-cost option is probably the wiser option.

Add us as a preferred source on Google