Skip to main content

Complete list of Reds' 2026 Rule 5 prospects (including one surprise who won't be protected)

Who's gonna get the call?
ByDrew Koch
Carlos Sanchez, Cincinnati Reds
Carlos Sanchez, Cincinnati Reds | Zac BonDurant/GettyImages

Despite the impending Major League Baseball lockout, the Rule 5 Draft is currently scheduled to take place next month at the Winter Meetings. Though the event itself is expected to be postponed (or canceled) the deadline for teams to protect Rule 5 eligible players from the draft — by adding them to the 40-man roster — is Tuesday, November 17 at 6 p.m. EST.

The Cincinnati Reds' 40-man roster currently sits at 37, meaning they could add up to three prospects without a corresponding move. Unlike most years, the Reds don't have a myriad of young players in line for a promotion to the 40-man roster, so the number of prospects added before the deadline could be very minimal.

But there's at least one lock to be added to the Reds' roster, along with a handful of borderline cases who could make the decision-making process an interesting one to watch. Let's breakdown Cincinnati's toughest Rule 5 choices, including one that might make fans a bit uneasy.

Carter Graham, Reds infield/ outfield prospect

The most obvious Reds prospect who'll be added before Tuesday's deadline is Carter Graham. The slugger broke out in a big way this past season. He hit .300/.421/.565 with 29 big flies and a 151 wRC+. Cincinnati would be out of their minds to leave the 25-year-old unprotected, and he could even make a play for a midseason call-up in 2027.

Prediction: Added to the Reds' 40-man roster

Ruben Ibarra, Reds infield prospect

Ruben Ibarra crushed 25 home runs in 2026 and posted a respectable .337 on-base percentage. The former fourth-round draft pick has massive power in that bat, but there's a lot of swing and miss that goes along with it. He hit just .238 at Double-A last season, and at such an advanced age (27), it's difficult to see Cincinnati adding him to the 40-man roster.

Prediction: Left off the Reds' 40-man roster

Carlos Sanchez, Reds shortstop prospect

Carlos Sanchez made quite a name for himself during his play in the Arizona Fall League this year, and it's not completely out of the question to think that Cincinnati might add him to the 40-man roster before Tuesday's deadline. But most of his in-season success came at High-A last season, and it's difficult to see another organization taking a flier on a player who hit just .214 with an 84 wRC+ at Double-A in 2026.

Prediction: Left off the Reds' 40-man roster

Jay Allen II, Reds outfield prospect

Jay Allen II was the 30th-overall pick in the 2021 MLB Draft, and he finally started to live up to the hype this season. In total, he posted a .267/.364/.438 slash line, but his short stint at Triple-A (.211/.318/.250) left a lot to be desired. Allen is a stellar athlete, but it's doubtful that'll be enough to convince another team to select him in the Rule 5 Draft.

Prediction: Left off the Reds' 40-man roster

Yerlin Confian, Reds outfield prospect

Much like the aforementioned Carlos Sanchez, Yerlin Confidan enjoyed a breakout performance in the Arizona Fall League this year. But his overall numbers during the 2026 season (.255/.332/.405 with a 90 wRC+) are unlikely to pique the interest of teams during the Rule 5 Draft. There's big-time power in Confidan's bat, but he'll need more time in the minors before making the leap to the big leagues.

Prediction: Left off the Reds' 40-man roster

Jose Acuña, Reds pitching prospect

This will be an intriguing name to watch. Jose Acuña came to Cincinnati by way of the 2022 trade with the New York Mets that also brought Héctor Rodríguez into the Reds' organization. Acuña made 25 starts between Double-A and Triple-A last season and struck out 23.8% of the opposing batters he faced. This might be one of the Reds' most difficult Rule 5 decision, and because of their need for rotation depth, don't be stunned if they add the 23-year-old to the 40-man roster.

Prediction: Added to the Reds' 40-man roster

Cam Collier, Reds infield prospect

Cam Collier is easily the most recognizable name among the Reds' prospects who are Rule 5 eligible, and may provide Cincinnati's front office with the most difficult decision. He spent all last season at Double-A and hit only .209/.286/.368, but managed to launch 18 homers and closed out the year hitting .342/.435/.430. Collier's a former first-round pick, has a Major League pedigree, and plays a position of need for Cincinnati (third base).

But these 40-man spots are valuable. Collier's still just 21 years old and has yet to play above Double-A. Is there a team out there willing to select him in the Rule 5 Draft and carry him on their active roster through the entire 2027 season? That seems unlikely, and while Cincinnati's brass usually plays it safe, don't be stunned if they leave Collier unprotected.

Prediction: Left off the Reds' 40-man roster

Other Reds prospects who are eligible for the Rule 5 Draft

  • C, Michael Trautwein
  • RHP, Brody Jessee
  • RHP, Hunter Parks
  • 3B, Ricky Cabrera
  • RHP, Cody Adcock
  • LHP, Bryce Hubbart
  • RHP, Jared Lyons
  • SS, Dominic Pitelli
  • RHP, Ty Floyd
  • LHP, Nick Sando
  • RHP, Kevin Abel
  • RHP, Johnathan Harmon
  • OF, Johnny Ascanio
  • OF, Shane Sasaki
  • C, Cade Hunter
  • RHP, Logan Tanner
  • LHP, Nate Peterson
  • RHP, Ben Wereski
  • C, Connor Burns
  • RHP, Jose Montero
  • RHP, Ben Brutti
Add us as a preferred source on Google