Skip to main content

Reds should ignore the left-handed reliever frenzy and stick with what works

This guy has proven he deserves to be back.
ByStephen Parello
Brock Burke, Cincinnati Reds
Brock Burke, Cincinnati Reds | Jeff Dean/GettyImages

With a 4.68 ERA in 2026 that ranked 25th in the majors, the Cincinnati Reds have a lot of work to do to get their bullpen right ahead of 2027. That hole got even greater when Emilio Pagan bolted for the Detroit Tigers earlier this month.

Losing the back-end anchor could up the pressure to add a high-end relief ace. After David Bednar accepted the qualifying offer to remain with the New York Yankees, the market will get even hotter for the remaining top options, almost all of which are left-handed. It'd be lovely to nab a guy like Adrian Morejon or Alex Vesia, two dynamic southpaw strikeout artists, but it's going to be really tough.

Morejon's market is expected to explode, with MLB Trade Rumors predicting that he'll receive a five-year, $80 million deal, which would be one of the largest contracts ever given to a reliever. Vesia won't reach those heights, but with a return to the Los Angeles Dodgers on the table as well as interest from the Yankees and other big-market teams, he's going to get paid, too.

If the Reds were to pull the trigger on one of these highly coveted players, they'd get a big name, but they'd also find themselves stuck in the mud. The bullpen needs more than just one addition, and blowing the budget on one of these high-octane arms would also ensure that Cincinnati is unable to address the rest of the multitude of needs that exist up and down the roster.

Instead, the Reds need to be looking to get the most bang for their buck, and a familiar face in Brock Burke should be at the top of their list.

Brock Burke can give the Reds 90% of the production of the top-tier options for a fraction of the cost

For as bad as the Reds' bullpen was this year, the lefties were significantly better than the righties. Cincinnati southpaws combined for a 14th-ranked 3.71 ERA. Burke was a big reason why.

The former Texas Ranger and Los Angeles Angel threw 74⅓ of the 170 innings the Reds received from lefties, posting a 2.30 ERA along the way. He alone was responsible for the left-handers' rise.

Burke was tough on left-handed hitters, allowing just a .195 batting average against, but he wasn't a one-trick pony either. He also was dominant against righty bats, yielding a .208 average. In high-leverage situations, the 30-year-old was virtually unhittable, giving up a .075 batting average.

On top of all of that, Burke's second half was ridiculous, posting a 1.21 ERA over 29⅔ innings. That includes nine scoreless innings in September. Burke also excelled in Great American Ball Park's unfriendly confines, which is a place not all are a fit for, posting a 1.38 ERA at home.

When you find something that works, don't change it. That's the case here with Burke, and he'll fly under the radar and still be a good deal cheaper than the glitzier names. That will allow Cincinnati to have more to spend to add more arms in the bullpen, as well as address their other holes.

Burke was great all year, but his second half hints at bigger things to come. There are two things he can improve upon as well, as he arrived in Cincinnati as a guy known for limiting walks and generating ground balls. In 2026, he saw his walk rate rise from 7% to 12.7% and his ground ball rate fall from 50.6% to 38.7%. If he gets these two skills back working, he'll be a true monster, and the Reds must capitalize and bring him back.

Add us as a preferred source on Google