The deadline for the Rule 5 Draft has come and gone, with eligible prospects needing to be added to the 40-man roster on November 17. The Cincinnati Reds, somewhat surprisingly, decided to leave Cam Collier unprotected as the deadline came and went.
Now, in most years, this would be a huge deal. The Rule 5 Draft occurs during the Winter Meetings in December, but this year we might be in the throes of a lockout by then. There is no guarantee that the Rule 5 Draft will happen, but there have been rumblings that it will be rescheduled, so this deadline was not merely a formality.
With this in mind, there's a real threat that someone could select Collier and the Reds could lose the young slugger for nothing. It's worth remembering that Collier was once one of Cincinnati's brightest prospects, coming in at No. 4 on MLB Pipeline's top-30 at the start of 2025. Injuries derailed his 2025 campaign, setting the scene for a critical 2026 season.
Unfortunately, Collier didn't rise to the occasion. His power was sapped due to a thumb injury in 2025, and with a bounce-back, he could've been in line for a 2027 roster spot. He found his home run swing again, raising his dinger total from four to 18 this year, but he fell flat everywhere else, slashing .209/.286/.368 down in Chattanooga.
In an ideal world, he'd be up next year manning the corner opposite Sal Stewart and proving himself to be part of the Reds' core, so the choice to leave him out in the wilderness could seem like the club cutting bait. That's not the case, though, and the lockout is the reason why.
The Reds were probably right to leave Cam Collier off the 40-man roster due to the impending lockout
If we're being honest, the risk that Collier is selected after a year like last year is low. The 22-year-old has yet to play in Triple-A, so while there's a chance that someone believes he can make the jump from Double-A to the majors, it isn't likely.
Even if a team loved Collier and was willing to select him, they'd have to carry him on the major league roster for the entire season, or else he'd have to be offered back to Cincinnati. In a normal year, the Reds might not want to risk this and have it all click for Collier in a new setting, but this year things are different.
That's because once the lockout takes place, MLB teams will be barred from having contact with any players on their 40-man rosters. On top of that, players on the 40-man roster, even if they aren't on the 26-man roster, will not be permitted to play in the minors.
While we hope that the lockout doesn't last too long, the latest saber-rattling between Rob Manfred and the MLBPA makes it seem as if the salary cap sticking point isn't going away and could make this thing drag on. If the work stoppage continues into the regular season, a prospect on the 40-man roster will suffer.
With Collier's struggles in 2026, having him miss up to an entire year of development time is a greater risk than losing him in the Rule 5 Draft. So, either way, the Reds were facing a gamble, but it makes far more sense to hope for the best and leave Collier unprotected so that he can get some much-needed minor league reps and hopefully get back on track. If he does, the Reds will have another young slugger ready to make an impact.
