Reds kept JJ Bleday at the deadline and the payoff remains uncertain

Playing on a cheap, one-year deal makes JJ Bleday's performance this season a pretty big win for a Cincinnati Reds squad that hasn't had many of those to speak of, even if consistency has evaded him.

He entered play on June 4 with a 1.003 OPS through 33 games, but since then, it's been a steady, gradual decline into mediocrity. Through 122 games, he owns a .740 OPS and a 103 wRC+. That's a respectable mark, but it's far from the breakout player Reds fans thought we were getting back in May.

Bleday's hot streak made him an oft-rumored trade candidate around this year's deadline. The Reds decided not to move him, and his decline has only become more stark during the second half. Failing to deal him at the peak of his value looks like a missed opportunity, but there's reason to believe he can still be a valuable piece heading into next season.

JJ Bleday's value shouldn't be lost on the Reds as 2026 season winds down

Let's not pretend as though Bleday is capable of playing like his spring self on a full-time basis; there was a point this season when his only peers — in terms of ard-hit rate — were Munetaka Murakami, Oneil Cruz, James Wood, and Jordan Walker. That's not going to happen again, at least not over an extended period of time.

Nevertheless, Bleday is capable of reaching a high bar when things are clicking. It was just a few weeks ago that he hit for the eighth cycle in franchise history, and that game marked his fourth this season with multiple extra-base hits. It's also worth noting that his career walk rate (12%) and isolated slugging (.185) are higher than the league average since he debuted in 2022.

As an occasional power threat with a knack for getting on base, there's value in what Bleday brings to a lineup, and that's especially true against right-handed pitching (.223/.342/.446 with 17 home runs and a 117 wRC+).

Considering how little competition there is for outfield reps in Cincinnati right now, it's hardly a bad thing that the Reds have an above-average hitter under team control through 2028. At worst, Bleday's presence on the roster is akin to Tyler Naquin's time with the Reds in 2021 and 2022.

There's absolutely a case to be made that moving him at the deadline would have been the prudent move, but that's water under the bridge at this point. Bleday is still around, and despite his summer slump, that could be a good thing with so many unknowns heading into the upcoming offseason.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow