While the 2026 season has started going off the rails for the Cincinnati Reds, there's a silver lining. The Reds have a number of assets that will be attractive to the true contenders around the league, many of whom are of the most valuable class: expiring contracts.
While packing it in doesn't seem appealing, there's a reason it might be an irresistible path forward for Cincinnati. The National League has a few defined contenders, with the Central being the most competitive division. In the American League, however, nearly every team is alive in the wild card chase. With so many teams having dreams of the postseason, it will be an extreme sellers' market.
The Reds will have a wide variety of wares to peddle at the Aug. 3 deadline, including the entire block of free-agents-to-be, a list that includes Eugenio Suarez, Brady Singer, Tyler Stephenson, Nathaniel Lowe, Brock Burke, Caleb Ferguson, Pierce Johnson, and Sam Moll.
Some of the players on the list play positions that will be in high demand at the deadline as well. If the Reds were to sell off just the expiring players, it might be seen as waving the white flag and restarting the rebuild, but it would actually be a different animal.
Reds can stock up and regroup for 2027 by capitalizing on an extremely favorable trade market
One might wonder why contenders would want to consider many of the players on this lengthy list, given that a decent number of them are responsible for the Reds' current predicament. It's a worthwhile point, but only to an extent.
Take Eugenio Suarez, for example. The slugging third baseman has struggled mightily this year, but his season has been a bit disjointed due to his oblique injury that limited him early on. Not only that, but he has a reputation as being one of the highest-impact power bats out there. That matters in terms of his trade value.
Another market the Reds can corner is that of left-handed relievers. Burke has been one of the few stalwarts Cincinnati could count on all season long. Ferguson has been equally good, if not more so, since returning from the IL. Even Moll has some value. The pool of relievers expected to be available is underwhelming, and it's always harder to find quality southpaws than it is to find righties.
Here's the big benefit to the Reds. While the club came into the season with one of the better farm systems in the game, the graduations of Sal Stewart and Rhett Lowder are sure to have the midseason update show a drop. Getting an influx of young talent into the pipeline, especially for a swath of players that likely won't be a part of next year's roster, is a big win.
The Reds wouldn't be taking a step back by following this strategy — they would be regrouping. The chances of competing within the division are slim, so capitalizing to build better for the future is key.
Cincinnati's core, players like De La Cruz, Stewart, Hunter Greene, Chase Burns, and Nick Lodolo, would still be intact. The depth in the farm system would be raised. And finally, Nick Krall would have another shot at being better and more efficient with building a supporting cast around that core.
The Reds could then try out other intriguing players down the stretch to gather clarity on what their future could hold. Guys like Michael Toglia and Chase Petty (as a starting pitcher) could benefit from some prolonged big league exposure as they try to carve out MLB roles.
Accepting reality and rebalancing assets for the future is the best course of action. It won't mean the Reds retreat completely, but it could end up creating a better, more well-rounded team in 2027 and beyond. That merits some heavy consideration given how crazy the market will be.
