Skip to main content

Reds could turn Nationals' DFA into a reunion years in the making

A much-needed redo after eight years.
ByBrandon Glick
Washington Nationals pitcher Josiah Gray.
Washington Nationals pitcher Josiah Gray. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Cincinnati Reds do not have a sterling trade history with the Los Angeles Dodgers, and their ill-fated attempt to bring the magic of Yasiel Puig and Matt Kemp to the Queen City looms large within that pantheon. That blockbuster yielded little directly for either team, though the Dodgers parlayed the prospects they got into much bigger deals.

Notably, Josiah Gray was moved just six months after the Reds drafted him in 2018, became a top prospect in LA, and was then traded once again to the Washington Nationals in the Max Scherzer blockbuster of 2021. That's a pretty convoluted road to the majors for a player who was drafted in the top 75, but Gray made good on his potential by becoming an All-Star in 2023 and the Nats' Opening Day starter the following season.

Unfortunately, injuries have tanked his stock ever since, to the point where he became a 40-man roster casualty this week. Now available on waivers, it might behoove the Reds to pursue a full-circle reunion with Gray eight years after trading him.

The Reds should take a shot in the dark on old friend Josiah Gray after Nats' DFA

Gray is exactly the kind of low-risk, high-upside pitcher the organization should be targeting this offseason. Back in 2023, he was one of the rising stars of the sport, recording a 3.91 ERA in 30 starts as a 25-year-old. His underlying data wasn't great, but it was easy to believe in the raw stuff. That is, until arm injuries began haunting Gray at every turn, forcing him to miss nearly all of the past three seasons.

It's undeniable that any organization that takes a chance on the 28-year-old will be betting on an old scouting report that may no longer be relevant; since 2024, Gray has thrown a total of 12⅓ innings in the big leagues. There just isn't anywhere near enough data for us to analyze or determine whether or not he can still get MLB hitters out with regularity.

Which is exactly why a team like the Reds is the perfect destination for him. They have a locked-in starting five — what they really need is depth. That's the kind of low-pressure situation Gray is deserving of, with the possibility of taking on bulk relief work if everyone stays healthy and he needs additional time to ramp back up to a starter's workload.

Considering he earned just $1.35 million in arbitration this past season, he projects to be a cheap source of rotation depth for his next team. The Reds would be wise to give him another chance with a change of scenery, at least if they still believe in the profile they drafted all those years ago.

Add us as a preferred source on Google