The Cincinnati Reds really missed Nick Martinez in 2026. Reports emerged after the regular season came to a close that Nick Krall preferred to sign Martinez rather than reuniting with Eugenio Suárez, but ownership's preference was to bring Geno back to the Queen City.
As the Reds enter the 2026-27 offseason — one that might only last another week or so — it's apparent that Cincinnati needs to find a Martinez-type pitcher who can give them extended innings out of the bullpen, and maybe even a start or three on short notice.
Though Martinez himself is a free agent once again this offseason, he's likely in line to receive a multi-year deal worth at least $20 million per season. That number would push Cincinnati's budget well past what they're willing to spend on a middle-of-the-rotation arm, but that doesn't mean that other pitchers can't offer a similar profile at a lower price.
Cal Quantrill could provide the Reds with that Nick Martinez-type hybrid they were missing in 2026
Cal Quantrill, who suited up for the Texas Rangers last season, could be a nice alternative and he has a relationship with both Reds manager Terry Francona and new pitching coach Joe Torres from their time together with the Cleveland Guardians. This seems like the type of pitcher the Reds should focus on before the offseason likely comes to a screeching halt on December 1.
Quantrill had a down-year in 2025 split between the Miami Marlins and Atlanta Braves, but he shook the dust off his cleats last season and had a nice bounce-back campaign with the Rangers. The soon-to-be 32-year-old righty posted a 2.86 ERA over 110 innings of work while making 32 appearances, including 15 starts.
Quantrill is not a high strikeout guy (18.3% K rate in 2026), but he keeps the free passes to a minimum (5.6% BB rate in 2026) and induced plenty of soft contact last season. Like Martinez, Quantrill does a phenomenal job of keeping the opposition off balance thanks to a large repertoire of pitches that includes six different offerings. He relies heavily on his sinker (especially against right-handed hitters), but mixes in a curveball and cutter against lefties.
As far as a price tag goes, that's anyone's guess. The best comp, however, might be the two-year, $24 million deal Cincinnati handed over to Martinez ahead of the 2023 season. The contract included an opt-out after the first year, a feature Martinez exercised before being extended a qualifying offer the following offseason.
We've been hitting on this theme since the offseason began; if the Reds' front office intends to compete in 2027, they must make smart, savvy signings and trades this winter. Inking Quantrill to a one or two-year deal would certainly qualify.
