Skip to main content

Frankie Montas may offer the Reds a low cost reunion worth exploring (but on one condition)

He's looking surprisingly good.
ByStephen Parello
New York Mets starting pitcher Frankie Montas (47) delivers a pitch
New York Mets starting pitcher Frankie Montas (47) delivers a pitch | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

We've said it time and time again, but this offseason's success will be determined by how creative the Cincinnati Reds can get. Making bold (but financially prudent) moves and having a little bit of luck break their way will be paramount, especially on the pitching side of things, where there are so many needs.

With that, we're going to throw out an idea that seems crazy at first glance. The Reds should consider re-signing Frankie Montas. You may have forgotten about him after a nondescript half-season in Cincinnati and the last two seasons being nearly completely wiped out by injury, but now that he's recovered from Tommy John surgery, he's attempting a comeback.

Montas recently threw a bullpen session, and Will Sammon and Denis Lin of The Athletic had some interesting notes from his showing. Up to 24 teams were in attendance, with some sending general managers and other high-ranking officials. Montas was throwing an easy 95, running it up at times to 98 miles per hour. Folks came away impressed.

"Evaluators said that based on Tuesday’s workout, they would recommend their clubs sign him to a major-league contract. The sources pointed to the lack of intriguing options in this year’s free-agent class as another reason to like Montas," Sammon and Lin reported.

The Reds could find that Frankie Montas can solve a problem, but not the one that fans might expect

While it seems that interest in Montas is high, it's unlikely that a bidding war will ensue. When the insiders are talking about him signing a major league contract, we're not talking about him landing anywhere for more than a couple of million dollars.

Because of the durability issues and how they've clearly impacted his performance on the field, it's difficult to remember that Montas was once one of the game's rising young stars on the mound. He finished sixth in the AL Cy Young voting as a 28-year-old back in 2021, throwing 187 innings with a 3.37 ERA and 9.96 K/9.

He began 2022 strong as a member of the Oakland Athletics, making 19 starts and posting a 3.18 ERA before being traded to the New York Yankees at the trade deadline. It was in the Bronx where things began to go off the rails. Montas posted a 6.35 ERA down the stretch, but this wasn't the case of a small-market player withering under Broadway's bright lights. Montas's shoulder was barking before he was even traded, and it ultimately required surgery.

He'd barely pitched in 2023 as a result, which was why the Reds were able to take a flier on him the first time around. He spent the year knocking off the rust over 150⅔ innings between Cincinnati and Milwaukee, and pitched just 38⅔ frames in 2025 for the New York Mets before the torn UCL sent him on another injury odyssey.

The thing is, while his later-career injuries are the most memorable, he struggled with durability early in his career, too. His 2021 campaign was an outlier for this reason. Before that 2021 breakout, he had never made more than 16 starts or logged more than 96 innings in a single season, and he debuted in 2015.

That's why the Reds can't count on him to fill a rotation spot, but as a reliever, Montas might be a true gem. He's always had electric stuff, which could play up even more out of the 'pen. The Reds arguably need to fill the bullpen holes with more urgency than the rotation, so they should strongly consider Montas for a bullpen role.

There, he would have a lighter workload and could have built-in rest days, preserving his health. His electric arsenal would play up even more in one-inning stints, giving the club the ability to find a high-octane reliever at a below-market cost. If Montas is open to the idea, the Reds must strongly consider taking the gamble.

Add us as a preferred source on Google