Latest 2025 MLB Mock Draft will excite Reds fans, but Cincy should stay the course

This isn't a bad pick, but...

Cincinnati Reds hat
Cincinnati Reds hat | David Berding/GettyImages

Bleacher Report’s latest 2025 MLB Mock Draft has the Cincinnati Reds selecting University of Arizona outfielder Brendan Summerhill with the No. 9 overall pick. While Summerhill has some raw tools—particularly his power potential—this selection feels like a complete misread of Cincinnati’s draft philosophy.

For years, the Reds have excelled at drafting and developing middle infielders and pitchers, and turning them into high-impact big leaguers. Their farm system is built around athletic shortstops and high-upside arms, not toolsy outfielders who lack polish. Given that track record, the organization would be far better off selecting a player who fits their strengths, like Eli Willits, Billy Carlson, or Cameron Appenzeller.

Latest 2025 MLB Mock Draft will excite Reds fans, but there are better options than Brendan Summerhill

Eli Willits (SS), Fort-Cobb Broxton High School (OK)

An Oklahoma University commit, Willits is the youngest legitimate prospect in the draft, giving him more developmental runway than almost anyone in this class. The Reds have a strong history of turning young, athletic infielders into MLB contributors, and Willits could be next in line.

As a switch-hitter with a polished offensive approach, he already has an advanced feel for the game. His defensive instincts allow him to stick at shortstop, but he also has the versatility to play elsewhere if needed. Willits' baseball bloodlines—his father, Reggie, played in MLB and coached at the highest level—only add to his appeal.

Billy Carlson (SS/RHP), Corona High School (CA)

Carlson offers two-way potential but is best projected as a shortstop with the ability to impact the game on both sides of the ball. He has a strong arm and defensive instincts that give him a high floor, while his offensive development could turn him into a five-tool player.

Carlson's athleticism and smooth actions in the infield make him an ideal fit for a Reds system that has had success developing premium infielders.

Camerson Appenzeller (LHP), Glenwood High School (IL)

Appenzeller would be the best option if the Reds want to break from their infield-heavy draft trends. The 6-foot-6 left-hander has gained 8-10 mph on his fastball over the past year, now sitting in the low 90s and topping out at 94.

With his projectable frame, three-pitch mix, and advanced feel for pitching, he fits the mold of a high-upside prep arm that Cincinnati could develop into a frontline starter. The Reds have shown they can develop pitching talent in recent years, making Appenzeller an ideal addition to their farm system.

Bleacher Report’s projection of Summerhill to the Reds makes little sense. Cincinnati’s farm system and player development strengths revolve around middle infielders and premium pitching prospects—two areas where Summerhill provides little value.

Instead, Cincinnati should focus on what they do best: developing elite infielders like Willits and Carlson or adding a projectable high-upside arm like Appenzeller. If the Reds want to maximize their No. 9 pick, they have far better options than reaching for an outfielder who doesn’t fit their strengths.

More Cincinnati Reds News and Rumors

Schedule