Deadline demand could keep perfect bullpen fit out of Reds’ hands

As the 2025 MLB trade deadline approaches, the Cincinnati Reds find themselves at a crossroads. They could either stay conservative and hope internal solutions hold, or strike boldly and fill a glaring late-inning need in their bullpen. On paper, the Washington Nationals closer Kyle Finnegan looks like a tailor-made fit. But in reality, rising demand and a potential bidding war could push him out of the Reds’ reach.

From the start of the season, the Reds have been pegged as a team in need of bullpen reinforcements. While Emilio Pagán has done a commendable job stepping into the closer’s role, there’s plenty of uneasiness that comes with relying on a reliever who's never carried full-time closing duties over a full season. The back end of the bullpen has been inconsistent, and Cincinnati ranks 18th in the league in relief ERA.

That’s why Finnegan, the 33-year-old right-hander, has emerged as an enticing target. He’s quietly put together another strong campaign, racking up 18 saves with a 2.96 ERA and a 1.24 WHIP. 

Kyle Finnegan’s trade price could push Reds out of bullpen market

According to MLB Network insider Mark Feinsand, Finnegan has caught the attention of multiple contenders, including the Reds, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies, and Toronto Blue Jays. And that’s where the problem lies for Cincinnati.

If the trade market heats up — and all signs point to it doing exactly that — the Reds may find themselves priced out. They’ve traditionally avoided overpaying for rentals and have shown reluctance to part with top-tier prospects for short-term fixes. That restraint could ultimately cost them a deal for Finnegan, especially if more aggressive suitors like the Mets or Phillies decide to push their chips in.

It’s a classic case of fit versus feasibility. For the Reds, the next few weeks will be crucial. If they make a strong surge and plant themselves firmly in the playoff picture, the front office could be more inclined to act boldly. But if the standings remain murky — or if the team falters — the idea of sacrificing future capital for a closer, even one as solid as Finnegan, becomes harder to justify.

The bullpen needs help. The perfect piece could be available. But unless the price is right, Finnegan might end up being the one that got away.

More Cincinnati Reds News and Rumors