Trading Nathaniel Lowe forces the Reds to get one thing exactly right

Fans thought that the Cincinnati Reds might have grand plans at the 2026 trade deadline. They anticipated the Reds would move on from a large collection of veteran rentals, headlined by Tyler Stephenson and Brady Singer.

Fans thought there might be a chance that they'd get bold with Hunter Greene and others. Instead, it was a ho-hum affair, with only Nathaniel Lowe and Caleb Ferguson moving on.

So much for a seismic event. However, in the wake of those two veterans getting shipped out is the arrival of a pair of youngsters. Chase Petty returns yet again to the majors, but this time he was accompanied by Cincinnati's No. 3 prospect, Hector Rodriguez.

This duo was likely due for a call-up regardless, but the circumstances around these promotions has a different feel given what just happened (or maybe better said, didn't happen) on August 3. That's especially true for Rodriguez, who essentially is replacing Lowe on the roster in a round-about way.

The Reds are trying to contend post-trade deadline, amping up the heat on Héctor Rodriguez

Veterans like Stephenson and Singer were said to be relieved to learn that they were staying in Cincinnati. That's understandable. We often forget about the human element of the deadline that often requires players to uproot their families, leave behind their friends in the clubhouse, and find new places to live, all while adapting to a new team and city on the fly.

But those veterans, and others, staying put also sends a message. The Reds aren't mailing it in. They're still trying to compete, and believe it or not, they still have an outside shot of getting back into the playoffs. As of August 5, Cincy is five games out of the final NL Wild Card spot. It won't be easy to erase that deficit, but it's possible.

Stephenson and Singer got off to slow starts to the season, but both have been very good of late. Singer entered action on August 4 with a 2.70 ERA since June 1, and then put forth a solid six innings of three-run ball against the Athletics in a winning effort. As for Stephenson, he's posted an .886 OPS since June 1.

The problem the Reds have really faced is that they need more, and that's where Rodriguez comes in. He's being tasked with replacing Lowe's bat, and the 31-year-old's .266/.341/.480 line sets a high bar. Theoretically, Rodriguez would have to match that just for Cincinnati to tread water.

That's a bit of an unfair ask for a rookie getting his first taste of big league action, so what really must happen is that other veterans need to step up, but Rodriguez must produce, too.

The 22-year-old has always been an intriguing prospect, but he seemed to truly level up this season at Louisville, hitting .274/.347/.533 with a career-best 27 homers over 104 games. That's exciting stuff, and if he can carry over some of that power and plate discipline that has made him a star in Triple-A to the majors, the Reds will be sitting pretty.

Of course, not all adjustments are easy ones. Edwin Arroyo was also scorching hot in Louisville, but couldn't translate that into even average performance in the majors. Just because Arroyo struggled in his first taste of big league action doesn't mean that Rodriguez will, but it is something to remember to avoid getting carried away while looking at gaudy minor league numbers.

If a firesale had occurred and been the impetus for Rodriguez's call-up, the youngster would have some runway to get his feet under him with minimal pressure on his shoulders. However, by more or less keeping the band together, Nick Krall has turned up the heat on Rodriguez to produce if the Reds truly want to climb back into the race. That may or may not be fair, but it is reality.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow