Skip to main content

Sal Stewart turned Rookie of the Year doubts into victory and now has a new target after Silver Slugger loss

Fuel to the fire.
ByDrew Koch
Cincinnati Reds first baseman Sal Stewart (27) reacts
Cincinnati Reds first baseman Sal Stewart (27) reacts | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Cincinnati Reds infielder Sal Stewart set out to win the 2026 National League Rookie of the Year Award this season, and he did it. Stewart overcame all the doubts (and all the haters) and took home the trophy just over a week ago.

Now Stewart has a new goal for 2027. He fell short in his bid to win a Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Award this season, instead watching NLCS MVP and former Milwaukee Brewers breakout star Jake Bauers take home the honor for the utility player group this year. But given penchant to prove the doubters wrong, he's likely to take this latest snub as motivation for next season.

Reds' infielder Sal Stewart could use Silver Slugger loss as motivation for 2027

If you'll remember, before the 2026 season even got underway, the doubters were out in droves. Stewart ranked fifth in a preseason poll alongside Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Justin Crawford and former Los Angeles Dodgers farmhand Zyhir Hope — a player who didn't even debut this season. A number of Major League Baseball executives claimed that Stewart was a "surprise" after winning Rookie of the Month honors in March/ April.

The once the season began to heat up, the critics were back again. This time they wanted to demean Stewart's efforts due to his lack of defensive saber metrics. The pundits (along with St. Louis Cardinals fans) wanted to chide Stewart's unimpressive amount of Wins Above Replacement (WAR).

But Stewart declared a war on WAR over the summer and had all the Cardinals' fans crying into the ether after JJ Wetherholt finished third in the Rookie of the Year race. We didn't even see Wetherholt's name among the Silver Slugger finalists, and he lost the Gold Glove chase to Brewers' second baseman Brice Turang. Maybe WAR isn't all it's cracked up to be after all.

Stewart plays the game of baseball with a chip on his shoulder, and after missing out on the Silver Slugger Award this year, Reds fans will likely see the budding star use it for motivation heading into 2027.

When Stewart puts his mind to something, he usually finishes the job. Next year could be a special season for the Reds' slugger. He can already check Rookie of the Year and All-Star off his list. Next up, Silver Slugger.

Add us as a preferred source on Google