Reds' unexpected surge vs. Mariners could ignite Cincy's true potential in 2025

Jackie Robinson Day in Cincinnati was already rich with emotion — a league-wide celebration of a trailblazer who changed baseball forever. But at Great American Ball Park, there were even more storylines swirling in the cold Ohio air as the Cincinnati Reds hosted the Seattle Mariners to open a three-game set.

Most eyes were on Luis Castillo, who was making his long-awaited return to Cincinnati for the first time since being traded to Seattle at the 2022 deadline. What many expected was a pitcher’s duel — after all, both teams have earned early-season reputations for strong rotations and not a ton of run production.

Instead, the Reds delivered a different statement — and it came from the group that had been scrutinized the most. The outfield.

It was a long time coming for Austin Hays. After straining his left calf just before the regular season began, the Reds played it safe with their offseason addition, shelving him on the 10-day injured list to avoid aggravating a nagging issue that had flared up during his time with the Baltimore Orioles and Philadelphia Phillies last season.

Hays had a scorching spring, slashing .310 with three home runs and 14 RBI over 16 games. But fans had to wait for him — and on April 15, they saw the payoff. In his long-anticipated Reds debut, Hays more than delivered. He went 2-for-4 at the plate, blasting a home run and driving in four runs as the Reds battered Castillo and hung six runs on their former ace, chasing him out of the game in the fifth inning. It was a cathartic moment for the frigid home crowd and a vindication of Cincinnati’s caution in getting Hays back on the field.

Hays wasn’t alone in lifting the Reds’ offense. Jake Fraley — mired in a slump to start 2025 — broke out  in a big way, going 2-for-4 to push his batting average back above the Mendoza line. Gavin Lux also turned heads with a perfect 4-for-4 night, driving in two runs and flashing the versatility that’s made him a valuable addition to the Reds roster.

The trio combined for eight of the team’s nine hits on the night, accounting for the bulk of the damage against a Seattle team caught flat-footed by an offense it wasn’t expecting. For a unit that had been labeled the weakest link on the roster, the Reds’ outfield looked like a strength.

With Spencer Steer still limited due to injury and TJ Friedl holding down center field, Cincinnati appears poised to lean into a mix-and-match outfield rotation. Fraley could platoon with the speedy Blake Dunn, while Hays — serving as a DH in his debut — will likely rotate between the outfield and designated hitter as the club manages his workload early.

The question now is whether this outburst was a one-night spark or a glimpse at a new offensive gear. If Hays can stay healthy and Fraley continues to trend upward, the Reds may have found the consistency they’ve been craving from the corners.

Tuesday's win may have marked a turning point offensively for the Reds. Between the long-awaited return of Hays, the timely resurgence of Fraley, and a statement win over Castillo, Cincinnati showed what it’s capable of when everything clicks.

More Cincinnati Reds News and Rumors