Reds' trade deadline strategy looks worse after brutal insider report

FanSided's MLB insider Robert Murray made a podcast appearance with Just Baseball Media and gave an absolutely scathing report regarding the Cincinnati Reds' strategy at this year's MLB trade deadline.

When responding to a question about the Reds' plans for the offseason, Murray couldn't help but cite numerous critiques from executives across the league, saying, "You're leading me down a rabbit hole. Their deadline was the most confusing by far."

"Every executive, and this is no exaggeration when I say this, every executive was absolutely befuddled with what they did and didn't do," Murray said. "It was bizarre. Like, Tyler Stephenson — their asking price was way too high — and there were teams openly mocking them for it."

Murray then spoke about the need for the Reds to build around their core during the offseason and concluded by saying, "They need to learn from their mistakes this past deadline, because that was, that was bad."

Wow! Wow! Wow! I think most Reds fans thought the trade deadline was a major disappointment, but this is next-level stuff, folks. Openly mocking Nick Krall and the front office? Are you serious? What a disaster!

MLB insider revealed Reds' disastrous trade deadline and it should cost Nick Krall his job

This is a devastating rebuke of Krall and the rest of the Reds' front office executives and it demands change. Unfortunately, I feel like we've landed here a lot — and it's going to be running theme until some changes actually take place — but this latest revelation from Murray shows you exactly what every other exec in the league thinks about the folks running the Reds front office. They're a joke!

Who's going to do business with the Reds this offseason? Nobody! Why would any other organization take them seriously? The trade market was begging for catching help at the deadline, but the Reds clung to Stephenson (who's a free agent after the season) like he was part of their young core.

Stephenson wasn't the only rental the Reds failed to trade. Cincinnati refused to move Brady Singer before the August 3 deadline. Why? What about Brock Burke? No other team wanted a reliable left-handed reliever with closer experience? I doubt that very seriously.

This was one of two things. Either Terry Francona convinced the Reds' leadership that this year's team still had a chance to compete for the playoffs, or the front office overplayed their hand. Either way, as Murray so succinctly put it, that was bad.

The Reds ownership cannot allow Krall and the other top officials in the front office to continue calling the shots after the 2026 season. Krall's contract situation is a bit of an unknown, though he received an unspecified extension in 2023. Regardless, once the final out of the Reds' regular season is made, Krall should be clearing out his desk.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow