Reds handed Noelvi Marte a challenge that could define his future (but it won't be easy)

Noelvi Marte appeared in just 10 games this season before the Cincinnati Reds made the decision to send him back to the minor leagues. He now faces an uphill climb if he hopes to return to the active roster this season, and his path back to the big leagues won't be an easy one.

One could easily make the argument that the Reds' coaching staff made the wrong decision to break camp with Marte on the roster. His spring training stats were nothing to write home about, and outside of his season-saving catch that helped push the Reds into the postseason, Marte's performance during the final month of 2025 was rather uninspiring.

Nevertheless, Marte was given two weeks to prove that his spring training stats were a mirage. Instead, his .138/.194/.138 line and 32.3% strikeout rate confirmed what his performance in Goodyear revealed — he needs more seasoning before being part of the Reds' everyday lineup.

Returning to the Reds roster won't be easy for Noelvi Marte

But Marte faces two different battles as he attempts to revive his career. First, he has to get his swing right. The 24-year-old was swinging at almost anything in sight, and as Cincinnati reporter Charlie Goldsmith pointed out, pitchers were noticing. More than 60% of the pitches Marte saw were outside the strike zone. That's an opposing pitcher's way of suggesting your plate discipline needs a lot of work.

But while Marte needs to improve that area of his game, he'll also have to contend with the trio of outfielders on the Louisville Bats roster. The hot-hitting JJ Bleday is just begging to be called up to the big leagues, and Blake Dunn and Hector Rodriguez have also gotten off to hot starts in Triple-A this season.

The Reds have said that Marte will be given time in both center and right field while he's in Louisville — and that's a wise approach. Cincinnati's long-term depth at both positions is questionable, so giving Marte plenty of runway to prove that he can play one or both positions at a high level seems logical. Few players in the Reds organization can match Marte's athleticism, so the switch shouldn't be a problem.

Perhaps it would be best for the Reds to give Marte the entire 2026 season to mature in the minor leagues. That may seem counterproductive to some, but seeing as how he's learning a relatively new position and the Reds have an abundance of depth in the outfield, there's little need to rush him back to the bigs if he hasn't made the necessary adjustments.

Both Bleday and Rece Hinds came out of the gates swinging, and proved beyond a shadow of doubt that they were ready to make the jump back to the major leagues. Hinds has since been recalled and it's likely that Bleday won't be far behind. Until Marte shows that kind of determination and production, Cincinnati's decision makers should be content to keep him in the minor leagues.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow