Skip to main content

Reds could take advantage of Orioles' logjam that they helped create

Let's help them clean up this mess.
ByStephen Parello
Baltimore Orioles second baseman Jordan Westburg (11) scores
Baltimore Orioles second baseman Jordan Westburg (11) scores | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

You know who would look good in the Cincinnati Reds' lineup heading into 2027? Christian Encarnacion-Strand. The Reds gave away the long-frustrating slugger for cash considerations, and then promptly watched him break out with the Baltimore Orioles.

We don't believe that the Orioles even expected the onslaught Encarnacion-Strand would bring on. Through 58 games, the 27-year-old hit .277/.325/.513 with 11 homers. Inadvertently, he's create a problem for Baltimore.

At the same time that CES began to ascend, the Orioles finally received what they'd hoped for over the last few years from fallen former top prospect Coby Mayo. For the season, Mayo played 132 games and hit .228/.297/.461 with 24 dingers, but from July 1 through the end of the season, he logged 223 plate appearances while slashing .267/.336/.550.

Baltimore has one corner of the infield locked down with Pete Alonso. When Jordan Westburg went down with a torn UCL prior to the start of the season, it looked as if they had no third basemen. Now, with Westburg set to return in 2027, these two youngsters rising, and the versatile Blaze Alexander also in the mix, the Orioles have quite the bottleneck brewing.

That could allow Cincinnati to swoop in and find a much-needed upgrade over Ke'Bryan Hayes at the hot corner, with Jordan Westburg seeming like an almost perfect target.

A trade with the Orioles for Jordan Westburg would give the Reds almost everything they need, save for one red flag

The Orioles are willing to listen on everyone on their roster not named Pete Alonso, so any of these options might be up for grabs. Baltimore's president of baseball operations, Mike Elias, is desperate for outfield help and is even considering using his infield surplus to paper over outfield holes. That sounds like posturing, though, and an actual outfielder would strike his fancy more.

Of all the potential options up for grabs, Jordan Westburg is the best fit for the Reds. The club has been there, done that with CES, shouldn't believe in a half-season of production from Mayo, and would be wise not to pay the exorbitant price the Orioles would charge for Alexander.

Westburg owns a career line of .264/.312/.456 and has been remarkably consistent over his career. An All-Star in 2024, he brings power from the right side and team control through 2029. He is also projected to make just $1.5 million during his first pass through arbitration. On top of all of that, he can play a decent third base but also has experience at second base and could displace Matt McLain should another corner infield solution present itself at some point this offseason.

There's one big hiccup in this otherwise perfect plan, though. Despite debuting in 2023, Westburg has played just 260 career games, and never more than 107 in a single season. The good news is that none of the various injuries he's suffered are of the chronic variety, but durability is a real concern.

That hasn't stopped the rumor mill from swirling, though. The latest smoke out of Baltimore is that several teams have called to check in on Westburg. Whether this is simply due diligence or a sign of a brewing bidding war remains to be seen.

Still, the Cincinnati would be wise to see what the deal is with the talented third baseman. If the Reds can dangle a package led by JJ Bleday to try to convince the Orioles to bite, it's something Nick Krall would need to strongly consider, even if Westburg's health issues are less than ideal. There might not be any other upgrade the club can get that's more impactful for the price than Westburg, so trying to come to a deal makes a ton of sense.

Add us as a preferred source on Google