Skip to main content

Reds could repeat last year's Nathaniel Lowe gamble with a new low-cost veteran

Why not?
ByDrew Koch
Cleveland Guardians first baseman Carlos Santana
Cleveland Guardians first baseman Carlos Santana | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Last February, the Cincinnati Reds signed veteran first baseman Nathaniel Lowe to a minor-league deal with an invite to spring training. Lowe made the 2026 Reds' Opening Day roster, and before being traded to the Cleveland Guardians at the deadline, hit .266/.341/. 480 with 17 doubles, 12 home runs, and 37 RBI. It's safe to say that Cincinnati certainly got their money's worth with that signing.

Perhaps the Reds should look to strike another such deal this offseason. Veteran infielder Carlos Santana isn't ready to hang up his cleats just yet — despite the fact he'll be 41 years old next season — and is hoping to find a landing spot in 2027. Cincinnati actually makes a lot of sense.

No, adding Santana isn't the type of free agent splash so many Reds' fans want to see this offseason, but adding the former All-Star would bring a veteran presence to the Cincinnati clubhouse; something that's sorely missing with the absence of Lowe, Eugenio Suárez, Tyler Stephenson, and Emilio Pagán.

The Reds should sign Carlos Santana to a MiLB like they did with Nathanial Lowe last year

Santana is coming off his worst season ever. He appeared in just eight games with the Arizona Diamondbacks, then suffered an adductor strain that landed him on the 10-day IL. He began a rehab assignment, but suffered a setback and was moved to the 60-day IL and later designated for assignment.

The Atlanta Braves swooped in and picked him up, but his time with the organization was an abbreviated one. He had just over 100 plate appearances with Atlanta's Triple-A affiliate, and was then released. In 27 games with the Gwinnett Stripers, Santana hit .292/.385/.382, giving rise to the idea that he could still be a contributor, albeit nowhere near the level fans have become accustomed to seeing.

So why take a flier on an aging veteran like Santana? Because he could provide mentorship to a young, developing star like Sal Stewart, and also allow the 2026 NL Rookie of the Year to move across the diamond on occasion and play third base. The majority of Stewart's reps in 2026 came at the cold corner, but given Ke'Bryan Hayes' struggles last season, the Reds have to have a contingency plan in place for 2027. Moving Stewart to the hot corner is the simplest solution.

Santana is a switch-hitter whose career splits favor a left-on-right matchup. But just two years ago, he hit .286/.356/.578 against southpaws. It would be sort of the reverse of the way Terry Francona used Lowe last season.

Speaking of Francona, he and Santana overlapped during their time in Cleveland from 2010-2020 (outside of Santana's one-year stint with the Philadelphia Phillies in 2018). Tito's familiarity would be an obvious draw that could lure the veteran to Cincinnati if he's looking for one last hurrah.

There's little that could go wrong with such a low-risk signing, and at the very least, if it brings a high-upside platoon bat to the roster for at little more than a minor-league deal.

Add us as a preferred source on Google