One man's trash is another man's treasure. That might be the case between the Cincinnati Reds and the Boston Red Sox. Both teams lost out on their Sonny Gray dreams, but the impact on their rotations is not the same.
The Red Sox were thought to be in the market for a Gray reunion because they need right-handed balance in their rotation. For the Reds, it's simpler; they just need arms.
There's no way the Reds were going to be able to afford the two-year, $55 million agreement that the Minnesota Twins gave Gray to return. Gray's deal was the second major free-agent starting pitcher signing, after the even more egregious three-year, $52.5 million contract Dustin May landed with the Chicago White Sox. The way the starting pitching market is moving is trouble for Cincinnati. At this rate, even more moderately priced options could rise to uncomfortable levels.
That could bring the trade market into focus, and the Red Sox might be able to help. Boston is said to be shopping some of its depth arms, with Johan Oviedo, Tanner Houck, and Kutter Crawford all hitting the trade block.
The Red Sox starting pitching excess presents intriguing buy-low options that the Reds should pursue
This trio isn't the typical group of buy-low starters. At one point, all three were thought of as rotation building blocks for the Red Sox, but in all three cases, injuries have derailed them. Now, Boston is simply looking to free-up 40-man roster spots in order to make other moves, and the club only has a tight window to navigate with the November 20 non-tender deadline looming.
If the Red Sox can't arrive at a deal before then, one or more of these players could be non-tendered. The Reds shouldn't take that risk, though. Boston isn't in a position to demand much, so Cincinnati should pick its favorite and send over a token to secure the hurler of its choice.
Oviedo, 28, is someone the Reds know well from his time with the Pittsburgh Pirates. He missed almost the entire 2026 season with a flexor strain after Boston gave up top prospect Jhostynxon Garcia for him last offseason. He's dealt with a variety of other injuries throughout his career, but his one full year as a starter came in 2023 when he made 32 starts, threw 177⅔ innings, and posted a 4.31 ERA. He's projected to make just $1.8 million in arbitration.
Houck, 30, underwent Tommy John surgery in August of 2025 and didn't return to action for Boston until the very end of 2026, making just one relief appearance. Like Oviedo, he's dealt with other injuries in the past, but when he was last healthy for a full season in 2024, he showed high-end potential, posting a 3.12 ERA over 178⅔ innings. His arbitration prediction is $4.1 million.
Crawford, 30, has also dealt with a litany of injuries during his career and was shelved for all of 2026 with elbow inflammation after missing all of 2025 due to a freak off-the-field wrist injury. He lasted pitched in 2024, recording a 4.36 ERA over 183⅔ innings. He's looking at $2.8 million in arbitration.
Oviedo and Houck are in their final year of team control, while Crawford has two years remaining. All three are risks, but they have mid-to-back-end upside, won't cost much in a trade, and carry ridiculously low salaries.
That last part is important. It would leave the Reds money left over in order to address other needs, whereas most free-agent starters worth their salt are going to blow through the budget. Cincinnati needs much more than one addition, so these types of gambles are necessary. Even more so if the Reds try to capitalize on a hot market and trade Nick Lodolo, adding cheap reinforcements will be paramount.
