Reds could bring back a franchise legend to mentor Sal Stewart

Sal Stewart’s MLB debut has been both everything and nothing that fans or he probably expected. The rookie, who sailed through the minors, gave the Cincinnati Reds a much-needed boost, but he also found himself in an unfamiliar position, literally.

With just two Minor League games at first base, Stewart has found himself manning that post in some of the most high-pressure environments so far. Luckily, the Reds have a legend who has been more than happy to help the next generation along.

Just two seasons ago, Joey Votto found himself training his replacement. During spring training and while on a rehab assignment at Triple-A Louisville, the former MVP took Christian Encarnacion-Strand under his wing as CES made the jump from third base to first. The relationship was a success, even if the results were not (perhaps due to the pressure on CES to fill Votto’s shoes). If Votto is willing, he could help Stewart thrive where Encarnacion-Strand struggled.

Joey Votto’s expertise at first base could be the key to unlock Sal Stewart’s potential

What Stewart needs is not so much Votto’s fielding skills; since Statcast began recording fielding data in 2016, Votto has a -25 outs above average at the position. Instead, Votto would provide Stewart with the poise and confidence required of a young star.

Stewart is already garnering praise for his work ethic and maturity. Learning from Votto’s experience of finding the joy in the grind could enable Stewart to be more comfortable and at ease in his new role and among his new teammates.

After all, Votto knows a thing or two about stepping into a tense clubhouse in September. When he got his first taste of the big leagues in 2007, the team had already fired its manager and was 14 games under .500. Pressure comes in all forms, and a team trying to find some light at the end of a horrid season can be as taxing as a team in the playoff chase. Votto stepped up to the challenge. In 24 games, the first baseman clubbed four homers and seven doubles. The team still went 10-14, but there was hope for better days.

Stewart can play that role for the 2025 Reds. Whether or not the team makes the playoffs, the end of the season will give Cincinnati something to build on. Votto was the runner-up in the Rookie of the Year race in 2008, and the team made the playoffs two years later. Perhaps with a little help, Stewart can provide a similar spark.

More Cincinnati Reds News and Rumors