We've already waxed poetic about how historically bad Ke'Bryan Hayes was at the plate in 2026, so we won't put you through that again. If you need the TLDR, just know that his wRC+ of 13 was the third-worst among every MLB hitter with at least 240 plate appearances in a season since 1940.
In other words, Hayes is unplayable. He's still a tremendous defender at the hot corner, but that isn't nearly enough to make up for his ineptitude as a hitter. Whether it was a mental block or some mechanical error that caused the decline is irrelevant; what is true is that the Cincinnati Reds are a worse team with Hayes on the roster.
Of course, that's not the kind of thing you want to be saying about the second-highest paid player on your roster. Hayes still has three years and $23 million remaining on his onerous contract, which is a lot of money owed the worst hitter in baseball. The Reds, naturally, will pursue every avenue to dump his salary on another team this offseason.
The problem is that other organizations aren't going to accept that baggage for free. And if they start asking for some prospect compensation in return, the Reds need to turn and run.
Reds can move on from Ke'Bryan Hayes without hurting their future
Salary dumps aren't the most common thing in baseball, but they do happen on occasion. The Reds have been part of a few themselves, including their decision to part ways with Homer Bailey in a veteran-laden deal eight years ago.
Of course, if you remember that deal, you'll know that they gave up top prospects Jeter Downs and Josiah Gray, both of whom would later be moved again in other blockbuster trades. That's the reality the Reds are facing with Hayes right now, though they probably won't get talent like Matt Kemp or Yasiel Puig in return like they did in the Bailey deal in 2018.
It's difficult to see a scenario in which Nick Krall surrenders a top prospect like Justin LeBron just to convince another team to take a chance on Hayes — but any deal for Hayes will require a legitimate prospect. The Reds already gave up Sammy Stafura in the original trade to land Hayes. Flushing more young talent down this toilet just isn't good business.
Would ownership be willing to eat the remainder of Hayes' contract if the front office designated him for assignment? They did it with Jeimer Candelario in 2025, which may have set an important precedent with these kinds of decisions.
