Reds accidentally found a Gold Glove finalist and created an offseason debate

The Cincinnati Reds have two finalists for the 2025 Rawling's Gold Glove Award. Unsurprisingly, midseason trade acquisition Ke'Bryan Hayes is a finalist for the National League at third base after recording 19 defensive runs saved (DRS) and 22 outs above average (OAA) at the hot corner this season.

In addition to Hayes, however, Spencer Steer was named a finalist for the NL at first base. When the team descended upon Goodyear, Arizona back in February, it was assumed that Steer was going to be the Reds' starting left fielder. A shoulder injury, however, threatened his status, and it wasn't until the final week of spring training that Steer was given the green light to join the Reds Opening Day roster.

Because of the injury, however, Steer was limited to DH duty at the outset of the season. He didn't take the field until mid-April, and at the time, because of his throwing restrictions, was only able to play first base. As it turned out, Steer posted terrific numbers there with 8 DRS and 6 OAA this season.

Reds accidentally found a Gold Glove finalist in Spencer Steer, but where will he play in 2026?

While Steer's defense was lauded throughout the season, one wonders if he'll be the Reds Opening Day first baseman in 2026. The Reds made the decision to call up top prospect Sal Stewart at the end of the season, and the 21-year-old's most likely position heading into next season just happens to be first base.

Cincinnati's acquisition of Hayes at the July 313 deadline caused a bit of a logjam at the hot corner. A third baseman by trade, Stewart's chances of supplanting Hayes in 2026 are slim to none. While Stewart's bat is far superior to Hayes', the rookie isn't necessarily known for his defense — something Reds manager Terry Francona prioritizes.

Once spring training begins, Steer is likely to get most of the reps at at first base, and is the odd's on favorite to be Cincinnati's Opening Day starter at the position. But a strong spring from Stewart could chance that narrative rather quickly, which will lead fans to wonder where Steer's defensive home might be next season.

This is a situation that will be settled on the field next spring, and the designated hitter offers the opportunity for both Steer and Stewart to receive plenty of at-bats in 2026. If Steer is fully recovered from the shoulder injury he suffered last season, don't be surprised if his defensive responsibilities expand next season.