3 Reds infielders that should consider a switch to the outfield
The San Diego Padres made a huge splash at the Winter Meetings in the wee-morning hours on Thursday with the signing of Xander Bogaerts to an 11-year contract. The surprising aspect of the signing is the fact that San Diego's infield is already loaded with talent.
Manny Machado, Ha-Seong Kim, Jake Cronenworth, and Fernando Tatis Jr. were already on the team, and now it appears as though Padres' manager Bob Melvin will have to reshuffle the infield. The Friars are expected to move Croneworth to first base, Kim to second base, and Tatis Jr. to the outfield in order to insert Bogaerts as the team's starting shortstop.
With so many talented middle infielders in the Cincinnati Reds farm system, the club may have to follow a similar formula in order to get their best players on the field at the same time. Which three infielders should consider a position change to the outfield?
1. Reds SS Jose Barrero should be moved to the outfield.
Now, don't yell and scream and curse at your computer screen. Everyone who watched Cincinnati Reds baseball from August through the end of last season understands that Jose Barrero struck out an inordinate and unsustainable amount of times during his first extended look at the major league level.
Those fans arguing that Barrero can't hit water if he fell out of a boat are not being overly critical, as there's no denying the .152 batting average and 76 punch outs that the infielder recorded in 165 at-bats for the Reds last season.
But there's two factors that cannot be ignored; Barrero had success and was named the Cincinnati Reds Minor League Player of the Year in 2021, and the 24-year-old was coming off hamate surgery as well. Not only did Barrero struggle in the big leagues, he was unable to put up good numbers in the minor leagues as well.
Jose Barrero has a cannon for an arm, and could be a very fine right fielder. If Barrero can regain the hitting stroke that he had in 2021, the Reds may have something in the Cuban. At this point, what does Cincinnati have to lose?
2. Reds SS Matt McLain should be moved to the outfield.
The Cincinnati Reds seem rather bullish on the idea that Matt McLain will be a major league shortstop. There's nothing wrong with that, exactly, as the UCLA product spent the majority of collegiate career at shortstop.
But, McLain does have experience playing center field. During his freshman year with the Bruins, McLain played 50 games in the outfield while also playing 11 at the hot corner. If nothing else, the Reds should at least experiment with McLain on the outfield grass.
This will not be a popular take after watching Nick Senzel crash and burn after Cincinnati moved their former first-round draft pick from third base to the outfield. But the truth of the matter is that Senzel's injury history began long before the Reds moved the University of Tennessee alum to center field.
While McLain doesn't possess Billy Hamilton-type speed, but he runs well enough to track down balls in the outfield; especially at Great American Ball Park. McLain also has an above-average arm that profiles well enough for him to make the necessary plays from the outfield.
The Cincinnati Reds seem set at second base with Jonathan India. Spencer Steer is reportedly going to get a long look at third base this year, and with Elly De La Cruz and Noelvi Marte knocking on the door, perhaps it's time to transition Matt McLain from a shortstop into a centerfielder.
3. Reds SS Elly De La Cruz should be moved to the outfield.
There's bound to be a lot of pushback at the idea of moving the team's No. 1 prospect from, arguably, the most valuable defensive position on the field, to the outfield. But there's plenty of merit to the idea of moving Elly De La Cruz away from shortstop.
For starters, De La Cruz stands 6-foot-5. That's gigantic for a shortstop. Occasionally, as is the case with players like Carlos Correa and Oneil Cruz, you'll see a shortstop that's 6-foot-4 or taller, but that's definitely not the norm.
Second, while De La Cruz is seen by a lot of scouts as a potential five-tool player, his offensive skillset is what's going to propel him to the major leagues. The Cincinnati Reds have better defensive shortstops, namely Edwin Arroyo, currently in the farm system.
De La Cruz is one of the most gifted athletes in the entire Reds pipeline, and if there's any player that would take the challenge of a position change and use it as motivation to get to the big leagues even quicker, it's De La Cruz.
Elly De La Cruz has only played on the infield dirt since becoming a professional baseball player. But if the Cincinnati Reds were able to transform a player with De La Cruz's potential into a capable outfielder, they'd have something special brewing in the Queen City.