Nick Krall just insulted Reds' fans intelligence with latest Ke'Bryan Hayes comments

Cincinnati Reds president of baseball operations Nick Krall made an appearance on MLB Network Radio during the GM Meetings this weeks, and Ke'Bryan Hayes became a topic of discussion during the program. But Krall's comments didn't seem to match reality. (Credit to the X account Gingersaurus Rex who provided the transcript from the interview.)

“Yeah, I mean, I think that Ke’Bryan Hayes had two injuries. He had a back injury and a hip injury throughout the year," Krall said. "Still an elite defender. If he can just get back offensively to where he was, you know, he’s a very productive everyday player in the big leagues. But he’s got to get there. He’s got to put the work in to get there this offseason and get himself healthy, ready for spring and ready to go.”

Reds fans won't fall for Nick Krall's foolish comments regarding Ke'Bryan Hayes

If he can just get back offensively to where he was? Is Krall serious? Where was he? Are we talking about the player who hit .234/.315/.342 after joining the Reds last season, or the one who hit .254/.307/.369 during a six year stretch with the Pittsburgh Pirates? Because neither one is what most would call a "very productive everyday player in the big leagues."

Hayes has become a popular punching bag throughout the city of Cincinnati, and with good reason. He was among the worst hitters in all of baseball last season, posting a .141/.194/.225 slash line with a 17 OPS+. For reference, that means he was 83% worse than league-average in 2026.

If you remove last year's disastrous performance from his ledger, you're still left with a player who owns a career 86 OPS+. Take out his worst season (2026) and his best season (2023), and his OPS is still sitting below .650 with an on-base percentage south of .300. Sorry, Nick. That's not "a very productive everyday player in the big leagues."

The Reds made a critical error when they traded for Hayes in 2025. No, Pittsburgh didn't swindle Cincinnati out of generational prospect — Sammy Stafura was traded to the New York Mets at the August 3 deadline and is still at High-A — but the Reds are now on the hook for the remainder of his $27 million contract that runs through 2029. As fans have seen over the years, these types of commitments force Cincinnati to cling to players longer than they should despite poor performance.

Krall's comments not only hide the truth, they indicate the Reds have no plans to part with Hayes this offseason. Nevertheless Cincinnati can ill afford to have such an unproductive player taking everyday reps away from the likes of Edwin Arroyo, Carter Graham, or any other top prospect. Another performance like the one fans saw in 2026 could (and should) result in a costly roster move.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow