Mets non-tender candidate could become an intriguing fit for the Reds

Due to the Cincinnati Reds' relatively thin budget, the impending lockout, and the dearth of quality bats on the free agent market, Nick Krall and the front office might find it difficult to adequately reshape a roster in desperate need of an overhaul. As such, the bargain bin, especially when it comes to non-tender candidates, is going to be the organization's best friend this offseason.

In that case, might Mark Vientos of the New York Mets be worth a look? He's certainly on the non-tender radar after suffering through one of his toughest seasons in the big leagues (78 wRC+, -1.1 fWAR). Even with a scant $2.4 million projected salary in 2027 — his first year of arbitration eligiblity— the deep-pocketed Mets may simply be ready to move on from their former top prospect.

However, that pedigree is worth noting, especially since it was just a couple of years ago that Vientos hit 27 home runs and posted a 131 wRC+. In that 2024 postseason, he hit a gaudy .327/.362/.636 with five home runs, and carried the Mets' offense all the way to the NLCS.

Though he's struggled in the years since, it's tough to find that kind of upside at that price. The Reds would be wise to pounce if he becomes available, assuming they can live with a few drawbacks.

Mark Vientos could add power to Reds' lineup, if Cincy's willing to live with his shortcomings

The question surrounding Vientos' defense are the real conundrum here. Unlike the upside he's shown at the plate, the 26-year-old has always been a net-negative on defense, with -10 outs above average (OAA) to his name at first base and -20 defensive runs saved (DRS) at third throughout his career.

That's a concern that can't simply be washed away, not after the Reds finished 27th in team DRS this season. But, regardless of Sal Stewart's primary position in 2027, there's going to be a need at one of the infield corners. As good as Ke'Bryan Hayes' glove is, he simply cannot be allowed to start with any regularity unless he proves capable of hitting major-league pitching again.

Carter Graham could earn a chance to be the long-term fit at first base, though he has yet to play above Double-A and is currently in the midst of a middling showing in the Arizona Fall League. The Reds probably need some type of bridge to to Graham (or Cam Collier), which is where a low-risk flier on Vientos fits into the picture.

A career .313 hitter at Great American Ball Park who has steadily improved at pulling the ball in the air throughout his career, Vientos would look good as a power threat in Terry Francona's lineup, especially if his .772 career OPS against left-handed pitching holds up.

Vientos' strikeout rates, lack of speed, and poor defense will likely keep him from ever becoming a star, but for a salary around just $2 million, his upside is worth betting on.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow