Former Reds standout trying to revive career could draw Cincy’s attention

The Cincinnati Reds’ pursuit of a power bat may drive former sluggers back into the fold. Whether by trade or free agency, possible reunions abound. Some players, such as Nick Castellanos, have the potential to instantly improve the Reds’ lineup, but others may relish the opportunity to return to Cincinnati to bounce back to form. One of the most enticing players for Nick Krall may be Jesse Winker.

Winker has been linked to the Reds in the past few offseasons, but perhaps this is the year that Cincinnati finally takes the risk of bringing the outfielder back. Winker’s return wouldn’t necessarily be cheered by fans. He can be volatile and outspoken, and he missed most of last season with a back injury. However, Winker could still serve as a low-cost option if the Reds are willing to take a risk.

Bringing Jesse Winker back has its risks, but the Reds may be desperate enough to sign him

One of the greatest downsides to signing Winker is his limited utility. For the past couple of years, he has mostly served as DH and only gets at-bats against right-handed pitchers. The Reds could certainly use another left-handed bat; TJ Friedl, Elly De La Cruz (switch), and Gavin Lux were the only regular starters that hit from the left side last season. Unfortunately, Winker’s injury history calls into question his ability to regularly slot into the lineup.

Winker’s back problems in 2025, which combined with an oblique strain to limit him to 26 games, seem to be a pattern. He has had multiple cervical (neck) strains and hit the IL with back spasms during his time with the Milwaukee Brewers in 2023. In his injury-plagued seasons, Winker has performed significantly worse than when he is fully healthy. These persistent injuries may dissuade the Reds from pursuing a reunion.

If the Reds do make an offer to Winker, their best option may be a Minor League deal. He signed one with the Nationals before his resurgent 2024 season, and he may need further rehab on his back to be game ready for 2026. In bringing Winker back to the organization, like the team did with Wade Miley in 2025, the Reds could stick to the budget, take a bit of a risk on a veteran bat, and still pursue other options on the free-agent market.