Emilio Pagán was about as affordable as a true closer can get. Simply by carrying that moniker, teams know that a reliever can handle the ninth inning, and price tags rise accordingly. So when Pagán declined his $10 million option with the Cincinnati Reds, it looked as if he was trying to parlay another successful season closing out games into a lucrative long-term deal.
That's what makes the one-year, $11.5 million deal he signed with the Detroit Tigers sting so much. Even more distressing, he was one of the first free agents to sign, coming to terms during the kickoff of the league's General Manager Meetings. The Reds already had a ton of bullpen needs, and Pagán's departure opens another huge one in the ninth. It's shocking to think that Cincinnati could get outbid by a measly $1.5 million after the 35-year-old just spent the last three years in the Queen City.
You can take an optimistic approach and say that the club is better off because it can take that money and spread it around elsewhere. With so many holes on the roster, it's a reasonable position to an extent, but $11.5 million split three or four ways doesn't go very far.
The pessimistic view is that this is another example of the Reds being cheap. Refusing to take even what many would consider to be a fair value and bring him back home because the price went up to a small degree. However, what's missing in that discourse is the fact that players have agency and can sign wherever they want to. More importantly, money isn't the only determining factor.
“I know I can throw in the ninth. I also know I can do other things. I’ve done it before,” Pagán told reporters in Detroit. “As long as we’re winning games and we’re battling for the division and in the playoffs, that’s all that matters to me.”
With those comments, Pagán laid out what truly matters to him. Having a chance to win is important, and after a last-place finish in the NL Central at 75-87, it's hard to make the case that Cincinnati was the place to make that happen. His next comments were even more damning.
"When the season ended, to be honest, I wasn’t sure what I was going to do. We leaned on my agent, Lee Long with Ballengee, and we came to the decision that it might be smart to be on the open market. And even still, at that point, to be honest, I kind of thought I’d end up back in Cincinnati. Detroit was a team that I was very interested in. We spoke with Detroit a good bit before I signed on with Cincinnati the last time, and so I had done my homework a little bit on the organization, on the team, on some of the players that were already there and some that are still on the way. There’s a lot to be excited about," Pagán added.
Emilio Pagan's comments highlight just how far the Reds are from being true contenders
Now one can say that both the Reds and Tigers were both 2025 playoff teams that failed to return to the postseason in 2026, and while that's true, it does feel as if they are moving in different directions.
It is true that Detroit lost Tarik Skubal at the trade deadline, but in the meantime, the Tigers might have found their ace of the future in Troy Melton, whom the club just signed to a six-year, $46.5 million extension after a year in which he put up a 2.76 ERA over 20 starts. The Tigers also have the 2026 AL Rookie of the Year in Kevin McGonigle.
You might think, so what? The Reds have the NL Rookie of the Year in Sal Stewart plus an even more electric young ace in Chase Burns. At the very least, both teams are even, right?
Except the supporting cast is very different. The Tigers have Riley Greene, a consistent power threat in the outfield and a three-time All-Star. They have a criminally underrated catcher in Dillon Dingler, who might be the best two-way backstop in the league. Detroit has another rising young player in Max Clark, too. There are several other solid veterans on the roster.
The biggest difference, however, might be highlighted when Pagán mentioned that the Tigers have more on the way. Detroit has the gems of the Skubal trade, River Ryan and Zyhir Hope, both of whom could be major factors in 2027. The Tigers also have an exciting infield prospect in Max Anderson and a guy in Josue Briceño who may ultimately put down the catcher's mitt, but has a bat that really plays.
Meanwhile, the Reds are devoid of top prospects ready to make the leap in 2027. Take the difference in supporting casts around the young, foundational players and add in a pipeline that has several impact players ready to contribute, and it becomes no contest. The Tigers are ready to jump back into the fray and contend in 2027. The Reds? Well, we're talking about trading Elly De La Cruz to reset the clock for the future.
The two franchises couldn't be moving in more different directions, and as much as Pagán enjoyed playing in Cincinnati, he knew the clock was ticking on his career and preferred to go to a rising squad versus getting stuck in the Reds' quagmire.
