Defensive struggles may push Reds into unimaginable trade for ex-Cardinals outfielder

The Cincinnati Reds’ decision to add Noelvi Marte to the outfield mix could be an indicator of any number of positive developments. Perhaps they’ll add old friend Eugenio Suárez at the deadline. Maybe Sal Stewart is on the way. Or on a more pessimistic note, maybe the existing outfield options just aren’t cutting the mustard.

Marte’s bat plays at any position, and his arm passed the eye test in his first outfield start. However, putting an inexperienced glove in a key position may create a defensive hole. Luckily, a familiar face on the trade market may hold the answer.

Defensive struggles may push Reds into unimaginable trade for ex-Cardinals outfielder Harrison Bader

Harrison Bader, one of the best defensive outfielder in the game, may be up for grabs. He has been predictably good in the field and has found his swing again as a member of the Minnesota Twins this year. Bader is already familiar with the nuances of Great American Ball Park, having played for the Reds in the latter half of 2023 and with the division-rival St. Louis Cardinals from 2017-2022.

The Twins moved Bader from center field to left where he has thrived, contributing 8 defensive runs saved (DRS). In his first season as primarily a corner outfielder, Bader ranks second among left fielders in outs above average. Gavin Lux, by contrast, is third worst in OAA and has the lowest success rate among qualified left fielders.

Adding Bader to the outfield mix in Cincinnati would shore up both the defense and the lineup. Connor Joe could finally be relieved of his duties as fourth outfielder, and Lux could focus on his best position: second base. A four-man outfield of Bader, TJ Friedl, Jake Fraley, and Will Benson with occasional help from Lux, Marte, and Austin Hays feels like the mix-and-match system that a strategist like Terry Francona would love.

Bader would also potentially be an investment in the future. His contract contains a mutual option for 2026. If the outfield mix works and if the Reds pick up both Bader and Hays’ options, the group will remain intact next year. With Hector Rodriguez as the only outfield prospect within shouting distance of the majors, stability across the outfield positions would put the Reds in a good position for success.

More Cincinnati Reds News and Rumors