4 Reds players who should also be signed long-term after Hunter Greene's contract extension

There were a lot of rumblings this past offseason about which Cincinnati Reds player would be the first to sign a contract extension. Turns out, it's Hunter Greene.

The Reds inked the former first-round draft pick to a six-year contract extension worth $53-million. According to our good friend Robert Murray of FanSided, the Reds hold a team option for the 2029 season and escalators in the deal could push the total value of the contract to over $90-million.

This is exactly the way the Reds will need to do business. The Cincinnati faithful know all too well that the Reds are not going to compete on the open market against the big boys. So in order to maintain relevance, the Reds need to extend their core group of players. Who should be up next?

1. The Reds should sign Tyler Stephenson to a contract extension next.

Honestly, this may be the most controversial Cincinnati Reds player who could be up for a contract extension, and here's why; is Tyler Stephenson a catcher, a first baseman, or a designated hitter?

He could be all three, and there in lies the dilemma when discussing a potential contractt extension. After injuries took their toll on Stephenson in 2022, the Reds made the decision to switch the 26-year-old from playing exclusively behind the dish.

Since the 2023 season began, Stephenson has seen eight games at catcher, three at first base, and has acted as the team's DH on five occasions. Finding a number that's mutually beneficial for both the team's primary backstop and the Reds front office will be a tough task for Nick Krall and Stephenson's representatives will be easier said than done.

Depending on the organization's long-term outlook, Tyler Stephenson should at least be considered for a contract extension in the near future. With so few options at catcher behind Stephenson in the minor leagues, it may behoove the Redlegs to ink the former first-round pick to a long-term deal.

2. The Reds should sign Nick Lodolo to a contract extension next.

Many Reds fans took to social media after it was announced that Cincinnati had reached contract extension with Hunter Greene to express their dismay that it wasn't Nick Lodolo. Many throughout Reds Country were claiming that the team "signed the wrong pitcher".

Now I'll be the first one to tell you that Lodolo may be the better long-term investment and could have a longer and more accomplished career once all the dust has settled. That being said, in no way to the Reds make a mistake by signing Greene to a six-year contract extension.

If anything, it sets the table and the market for Lodolo. Both Greene and Lodolo are former first-round draft picks, made their major league debuts during the same month last season, and both have had similar success at the major league level.

If Hunter Greene is viewed as part of the long-term plan, you'd have to assume that Nick Lodolo is as well. The left-hander, until Tuesday's outing that saw him allow eight runs in less than five innings, Lodolo had the look of the best pitcher on this year's Reds squad.

Be patient, Reds Country. Nick Lodolo will get a deal done as well. Will it be this season? Perhaps. If not, keep an eye on Lodolo as the offseason comes around. The Cincinnati Reds appear to be prioritizing their pitching staff going forward.

3. The Reds should sign Jonathan India to a contract extension next.

This one might be the most obvious, but also the most difficult to get done. First, I think it's fair to say the talk of Jonathan India's sophomore slump carrying into his third major league season can be put to bed. India, who's in much better shape physically this season, has looked great and it the unquestioned leader on this Reds team.

So why should it be so difficult for India and the Reds to find common ground on a contract extension. Two words - Scott Boras. That's right, the Reds second baseman is represented by one of the shrewdest sports agents in the game and Boras is always looking for his clients to make it past the arbitration window and into free agency.

In the past, according to NBC Sports, Boras refers to the type of contract extension India would be signing as a "snuff contract". Why is that? Because you're dealing only with one team, and in essence, snuffing out the player's opportunity to see what he might be worth on the open market.

Now, from the agent's perspective, Boras is 100% correct. If India, or any player still under team control, were to sign a contract extension, they're only negotiating with one ball club. It can certainly lower a player's value.

However, what if India puts up numbers like we saw in 2022? Then he'd love to have that "snuff contract", wouldn't he? The Cincinnati Reds should definitely approach Jonathan India about a potential contract extension. But Reds fans should know, it just might not be in the cards.