In his first 21 games as a member of the Cincinnati Reds, Shin-Soo Choo is quickly becoming a fan favorite. (Photo: David Kohl-USA TODAY Sports)

Cincinnati Becoming Choo-Ville


When the announcement was made of the three-team trade involving the Cincinnati Reds, Cleveland Indians and Arizona Diamondbacks in which the Reds acquired Shin-Soo Choo, there was a bit of a flinch from a portion of the Reds fanbase. One, highly touted shortstop prospect Didi Gregorius was sent to the D’backs. Two, despite the high number of strikeouts, Drew Stubbs, who went to Cleveland, had his fair share of supporters. Three, Choo will be a free agent after this season.

Twenty-one games into the 2013 season, I’m sure the vast majority of those that flinched at the deal aren’t doing that so much these days. All Choo has done is win over Reds fans at an alarming rate. Along the way, he has produced in the one spot in the Reds lineup that was deemed the blackest of holes: leadoff.

All Choo has done is produce. After going 2-for-4 in today’s Reds 1-0 win, he owns a triple slash of .392/.534/.608. They’re not quite video game numbers, but sometimes you think Choo’s just merely living in one. Aside from last night’s MLB action, here’s how Choo ranks in some prominent NL statistical categories…

Batting average: .392 – 2nd (Chris Johnson: .397)
OBP: .534 – 1st
SLG: .608 – 8th
OPS: 1.142 – 2nd (Justin Upton: 1.200)
Runs: 18 – T3
Hits: 31 – 1st
Walks: 14 – 4th
HBP: 10 – 1st

So the last one isn’t as prominent as the others, but those HBPs lead to the OBP. And the only reason Upton is ahead of Choo in OPS is because of Upton’s other-worldly SLG of .797. Of course, 11 homers can do that to your slugging percentage.

If you’re worried that he has 18 strikeouts, keep this in mind. Those 18 whiffs has his current SO% at 17.3%. Do I need to remind you what that rate was for Reds leadoff hitters last season? Well, it was 19.6% if you insist on knowing (148 SO in 756 PA).

For all of 2012, Choo’s SO% was 21.9% and in March/April of 2012, that was 22.2%. His walk rate this year is 13.5%. For the March/April of 2012, his BB% was 13.9% (a bit higher than this year), but finished the 2012 season at 10.6%.

Want a comparison? No, not going there about Stubbs either. The Tribe’s new leadoff hitter, Michael Bourn, had a SO% of 22.0% in 2012. His walk rate was 10.0%. Yes, I have noted these similarities before.

Back to the trade. I was a bit taken aback at the deal. It was more directed toward the fact that Choo had such a limited time as a leadoff hitter (98 games, but a nice sample size) plus the changing of leagues. For some players, that’s a tough ask. Choo had spent parts of eight season in the American League. Knows the pitchers, the ball parks, the stadiums, the clubhouses. Even with interleague play, there was still some familiarity that would be lost in the move.

And, add the position change to all of this. In the NL parks in which he had played, he was a right fielder. Aside from the one game debacle in St. Louis, there’s has been little else to complain about regarding his defense. He’s already nailed a runner at the plate and has exhibited a stinger arm than a few may have expected there. I will raise my hand on that one.

To say that Choo, which is what he prefers to be called if you take Reds broadcaster Chris Welsh at his word, has adapted to all this newness with flying colors is a vast understatement. To say his new city of Cincinnati has completely fallen for him might be on that same level if not greater. Probably could even beat Charlie Sheen in an election for mayor.

A bit of reality here. Reds fans shouldn’t expect Choo to maintain such a completely insane performance level. At times, it’s utterly ridiculous to watch – but in a good way.

And I thoroughly enjoy watching this ridiculousness…

Tags: Cincinnati Reds Shin-Soo Choo

  • Josh Bresser

    Choo’s been great on offense this year. Second highest WAR in baseball right now (behind, of course, Upton.)

    Although, his defense has been as advertised. The problem isn’t so much that he’s committing errors, outside of the aforementioned debacle in St Louis, but that his range isn’t at the level of a center fielder’s.

    The defensive stats (which, I find a bit meh anyway) support this, as his -2.7 UZR is well below average (actually, before this 10 game homestand, it was around -5, so road games could be a problem even more so defensively.) But, there have been more balls falling into gaps and in front of Choo that most CFs would have gotten to. Once I get some time, I’m going to try to find some footage of Stubbs’ CF work vs. Choo’s on similar plays. Needless to say, he’s been what mostly everyone expected on both sides of the ball- a potent leadoff hitter with a bit of a defensive liability attached. Although, if he keeps hitting like this, you could put Adam Dunn in center and it’d still be worth it.

    • Josh Bresser

      8th inning of this game is a good example, cost the Reds 2 runs

      • http://blogredmachine.com/ Steve O’Red

        Everyone was well aware of the potential pitfalls regarding Choo’s defensive liabilities in moving from right to center. Don’t care about his UZR right now. Don’t care about it at the end of the season either. If he was a cog in this so-called “New Red Machine” making a World Series appearance (at least), that’s all that matters.

        • Josh Bresser

          Oh yeah, like I said, if he keeps hitting like this, then they could put Adam Dunn out there and it’d be worth it.

  • Idaho Reds Fan

    I would like to know at what point (in what # game) last season were the combined leadoff hitters on base as many times as Choo already has been so far this season. If you told me the date was in June, I wouldn’t doubt you…

    • Josh Bresser

      Choo’s been on base 45 times so far. Stubbs wasn’t on base 45 times until mid-may.

  • Pingback: Three Up, Three Down - 4/25/13 (Reds @ Nationals) - Blog Red Machine

  • Pingback: Dusty Grabs No. 1,600 on Choo Walk-Off - Blog Red Machine